Post

hi Bluesky! 🦋 i’ve been chosen as the new head of product here at Bluesky HQ! and i couldn’t be more excited to hack with this incredibly talented team on making this site better for everyone.

295 reposts4.2K likes

since i started coding in my teens, i’ve been obsessed with making social apps and tools that let anyone build their own communities on the open web. no walled gardens, no shady incentives.

we all deserve more of the good parts of social media with less of the bad. that’s why i joined Bluesky. i personally want a better place to hang out and have real conversations online. i think the world does too. we have wind in our sails.

as head of product, my job is simple: listen to you and bring you more of what you want from social. first up… a feature so requested, we lost count of how many times you asked. any guesses??

Therein lies part of the problem, at least as I see it. Real conversations need to have depth and flow naturally without feeling restricted or corralled into a dumbed-down version of what people really want to say. Finding a creative way to introduce long-form content, while continuing to give...

I don't like how censorial BSky is. Somebody disagrees with you, and they block you. Fine. But the back and forth (such as it is) disappears. I was following a tasty thread and one guy in Singapore blocks a Canadian and now I can't see what was said by the Canadian. Which is some real bullshit.

The most wanted feature is “turn off reskeets per user” and they keep adding other stuff we don’t want. Please do this. We are begging. BEGGING.

Congratulations, Alex! When I deleted my account on the "Brand X" social media platform, I looked at where I wanted to move and selected BlueSky!!! I can't believe how far BlueSky has come in the last 6 months, and even better days are ahead. A big "Thank You" to you and the entire team!!!

It may not be as frequently requested but a suggestion: embed videos from Instagram and TikTok to reduce the re-hosting via re-posting. The goal here is to reduce (1) resources for Bluesky, (2) video feeds with filled with redundant videos, and (3) improve discovery of original video creators.

When I read something horrible like someone’s pet has died or something that ICE has done I don’t want to click the like button couldn’t you have another button like a lightbulb or something so we can acknowledge something without liking it.

I hope you understand that the less you follow in Twitter's footsteps, the better this platform will be. If you care about the product you will take it upon yourself to be the voice of pushback not to us the people but to your bosses.

I know we can disable reposts in the following feed but it'd be cool if we could specifically disable reposts of their own posts. For example I follow a lot of artists and they do great work but there's a tendency to fill the air while life gets in the way by reposting old work and there's nothing

wrong with that in any way, I'm just picky with my feed and I'd rather it not move until there's something new to see, if that makes sense, but I'd still like to see them reposting things from others. Unless that's how it already works in which case it should be a bit more clear.

HI Alex, congratulations on your position. Biggest request - if Bluesky will eventually monetize with adverts, please allow a paid subscription option where we can avoid them. The ads were the beginning of poor user experience and perception of product on twitter.

Good point. There should be an option to not see any media. Or have the media hidden by default until you choose to see what it is. If you're in a sensitive environment, never choose to see it. Barring that, a feed that hides all media posts could be a workaround.

Why am I getting inundated with women exposing their breasts. I keep blocking and keep getting them. As an 81 year old great-grandmother, I'm not all that shocked, but it is irritating.

Can you do something about the accounts reported for unwanted sexually suggestive content. Seriously. Unwelcome unsolicited pics of naked guys offering up their anus or view of their penis, video of two men having penetration sex… It’s too much. I don’t need that in my timeline of content. Thx.

One more suggestion is to work on the logged-out experience+SEO. Being an open network is a big advantage vs others which have largely closed themselves off to webcrawling, etc. The logged out experience on bsky.app hasn't improved since the public launch. Lurking w/out an account is important.

Welcome to the network, Alex. My strongest possible request/recommendation is to integrate Reddit-style subcommunities into Bluesky in a "native" way. I was on Reddit *before* subreddits and it was just HN, not appealing to most. Without subreddits, they would never have reached 1 billion MAUs.

Jake Gold@jacob.gold

This is The Schizophrenic Problem that Twitter never solved but Reddit did. People have moods and the algorithm has no way of knowing your *current* one is. No one is going *ever* in the mood for everything. There needs to be a way to select into specific kinds of content and *avoid* other kinds.

The important thing is to *truly* learn from Reddit's example and not just copy some aspects superficially, which will absolutely not work. Each community needs to be like its own Bluesky, with its own vibe, its own rules, its own moderators, and the rest. Hard to nail it but very possible.

1/ Hey Alex, wishing you great luck! I loved my time on the team there and am rooting for you guys. Reddit mostly nailed it with subreddits. The problems stem from them being a centralized and closed network. I've been on Reddit+Twitter since they launched and always believed they were merge-able.

Jake Gold@jacob.gold

Reddit is a closed network that wants to force-feed us ads, hold our own content hostage, force us to use their app, share our usage data with third-parties, etc. See this example, where they shutdown an app (Apollo) someone built to make using Reddit better that had 5 million installs:

another vote for a reddit feature: collapsing sub-comment threads. this is one of my favorite things in reddit. when an odd deep dive sub comment thread goes off, it has a life of its own but if its not YOUR mood you can just collapse it and go to the next comment at the level you're currently at

Moderation is a very tricky subject. A big part of the issue on Reddit was people who were moderators of hundreds of subs giving them effectively sitewide control with no accountability or transparency, plus all the normal problems that power brings.

Yeah it is but giving people power and letting users opt-in to succumbing to that power within a specified scope seems unavoidable if you want real and unique communities.

Feeds are cool but aren’t a substitute for real subcommunities. Can’t post into them or style them or moderate them etc. They could be upgraded but probably easier to just create a new thing.

Hi @jacob.gold would it be true to say that AT Proto should allow anyone to build a back end (and any number of user-facing products to run on it) that can do communities? I realise of course that right now the Bluesky team look like the ideal people to do this but theoretically anyone could, right?

Yes, anyone can built a new app that adds whatever functionality they want while incorporating any or all of the functionality that Bluesky already has. But, at least for now, Bluesky is the flagship atproto app with the flagship Bluesky mobile app, so adding it here is the highest impact move.

Congrats Alex! When will we get the feature of sharing images on the chat? Being mid chat with someone and wanting to share a photo and not being able to, feels like crashing on a wall while running full speed.

if you're building this out, also give me a small electric shock when I click "Show" on a post that contains a muted word

Give everyone 𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘩 𝘁𝗲𝘅𝘁, not just 𝕥𝕚𝕟𝕜𝕖𝕣𝕤 like me who go through the effort.💁 Rich text is something 𝘰𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 social media platforms frown upon... 𝘴𝘰 𝘦𝘮𝘣𝘳𝘢𝘤𝘦 𝘪𝘵!😁 I find it allows me to be a 𝘭𝘰𝘵 more expressive and I'd 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 stoop to ALL CAPS!🙄 I'm using this Chrome extension but there are other ways.👇

Just A Tinker 🟥🍁🟥@john-gardi.bsky.social

#BlueSkyHacks Here's two: B̲l̲u̲e̲S̲k̲y̲C̲o̲l̲o̲r̲P̲a̲l̲l̲e̲t̲S̲w̲a̲p̲p̲e̲r̲ Lets you change @bsky.app's look. 𝗖𝗵𝗿𝗼𝗺𝗲 chromewebstore.google.com/detail/blues... 𝗙𝗶𝗿𝗲𝗳𝗼𝘅 addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefo... 𝔾 ℝ𝕋𝔽: ℙ𝕝𝕒𝕚𝕟 𝕥𝕠 ℝ𝕚𝕔𝕙 𝕋𝕖𝕩𝕥 Add rich text like 𝐛𝐨𝐥𝐝 and 𝘪𝘵𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘤𝘴 to 𝓹𝓸𝓼𝓽𝓼. 𝗖𝗵𝗿𝗼𝗺𝗲 chromewebstore.google.com/detail/g-rtf...

That's true, I did notice my screen reader skips the rich text parts but that could be overcome easily enough. As a tinker, my first approach is always 'this can be fixed'. I have 10% vision & have modified many computers for accessibility for disabled folk so it's important to me to get that right.

Congratulations! Feature / update request: If you could make “mute account” actually work as it does on the bird app, i.e. no longer see posts from that account, it would be amazing. And it would make the “discover” experience way more viable. 🙏🙏🙏

Hi alex, congratulations on landing that job. I’m excited to see in which new directions you’re going to take the app. Speaking of which, any plans to tackle the currently hot topic of the content guidelines being too vague and open to interpretation?

Keep the credit card companies from censorship. Credit cards should never be a "morality gate keeper" Credit card companies should not be able to block legal purchases of G/PG/PG-13/ and Mature games. My bar for respect is so low. Don't let credit card companies be your master

Maybe something (hopefully) easy: Some ubb code for posts. Not much needed to give a post character; [b], [i], [sup]. Something hard: Image classifier for moderation. Lack of moderation for memes is a problem. >been chosen "Make him an offer he can't refuse."

Oh, gosh, I hope that’s a priority, too. While it’s nice not having algorithms dictate the general experience, unfortunately that makes people repost a *ton* more to compensate, and seeing the same post over and over, even over the course of months as different trends re-emerge, is tiresome by now.

I suggest making it easier for new visitors to find out how to use it. Making more likely they will stay.

My top request: can you make it so when I open the app, it’s where I left off on the timeline and I can then scroll up? Starting at the top and going backwards in time is hard to find what I read last.

I don't allow people to comment or share my posts because you don't have a way to block, delete comments, hide comments or ban users who post mean, inappropriate and negative things. Please change this to make BlueSky more usable. Model how even Facebook is set up to do this.

It would be nice to have an easy way to go back and correct typos on posts one has made. It seems the only alternative is to delete an old post and repost. Not very efficient!