Post

On Reddit, Orange County residents are very justifiably angry that local authorities are posting vital evacuation information on X and Instagram…which both require accounts if you want to be able to view videos easily and completely. How many people use neither? This has got to stop.

791 reposts2.9K likes

They should be posting this stuff everywhere people’s eyeballs are… including X and Instagram. They should be here too. They absolutely should post on their own websites, with both webpages, and RSS/Atom/CAP feeds, and/or use FEMA’s IPAWS system (which feeds mobile alerts, among other things).

No third party platform, including here, X, Facebook, Instagram, etc. should ever be the only, or even preferred, way to access this critical information.

I live in Tulare County in the Sierra Nevada foothills - fire country. We always get notifications from CalFire even if they aren't the lead on the fire event. I've never seen important fire info posted on social media that isn't distributed widely and requires an account, certainly never on X.

Having volunteered in multiple roles in local emergency management, these are some of the most responsive groups to community requests… people should reach out to them and explain why it’s not a great approach. Also, write city council, local reps, state reps, etc. 1/2

It’s definitely kind of a piecemeal approach but unless you can get FEMA to push out some guidance, I think it’s the best way to get there. Even so, it’s a pretty solvable problem compared to many in government. 2/2

A few years ago in Nova Scotia, some guy bought a used cop car, tricked it out as a real cop car, had a police uniform and drove around murdering large numbers of people, and the RCMP only let people know on Twitter So many people got murdered by this fake cop, real killer.

This is why I have not dumped Facebook and WhatsApp. All important information regarding where I live is communicated on those platforms. Road closures, storm updates, fire warnings, water turned off or don’t drink- everything. Eventually that info shows up elsewhere- but much later.

So yes, I agree Meta is highly problematic. I dumped Threads, got as many people as I could to switch to signal. But not being able to access critical information timely is bad. Now does FB put that stuff on my feed? No. Or late. I check particular pages after WhatsApp alerts.

I wrote about why governments must stop relying upon Facebook and X/Twitter to communicate vital disaster information to the public a while back - unfortunately, this issue is only getting worse. You can do something about it: write to your local authorities and demand they change their approach.

little-flying-robots.ghost.ioWe Have to Stop Using Facebook and X to Warn People About DisastersIn the early morning hours of July 4th, as the Guadalupe River reached catastrophic heights, city officials in Kerr County, Texas turned to an all-too familiar mechanism for getting the word out to ar...

Reading the article prompted this thought: both FB and twitter are declining and fighting for relevance. Wouldn't it make *a little* sense for one of them to do the work to become the must-have, go-to app for emergency comms? Be valuable for this function, and drive more users to your site?

Twitter was fantastic for Christchurch #eqnz . If it happened now I wouldn’t know where to go. BlueSky has an eqnz feed but it’s low activity. Some weather events are covered well-ish here. Does anyone know if Threads does disasters? I wish we had a reliable place.

Yes, that seems pretty clear, but I guess it doesn't have to make sense. FB would be a lot more useful to me if it would show me the local govt accounts I follow promptly instead of a week later. I would go to FB more often.

There are a healthy number of us who won't risk downloading apps from Musk & Zuck, at ALL. As a Californian, I don't understand why law enforcement & emergency alerts are so enmeshed with exploitative, data-invasive hell-sites. 🤔Sites run by architects of our destruction. Why expose us to them?

An interesting article and it seems criminal to rely on social media for critical warnings. In Australia, despite constant attacks from the far right politicians, the national broadcaster, ABC, has immense loyalty on account everyone knows to tune into ABC radio during disasters like bushfire.

In my area, there are very few people who can afford Internet service. Disaster messages passed out over Twitter/Facebook is a disaster of itself. Our county doesn't do it, but the state does.

It's not just an access problem; SM is a competitive environment for critical information and in a disaster situation, algo-optimized bullshit inevitably wins the first hour. Wrote this last year thinking about a potential nuclear war, but the case is being built with each local natural disaster

thebulletin.orgPost-truth disasters: We're not ready for nuclear war on social mediaRisks of a serious crisis are rising. But for disaster response, the information environment has never been worse.

Yup. I remember being in a restaurant in Greece when everyone's phone buzzed emergency and we got links to a site that in English and Greek told us of impending forest fire dangers.

Why aren’t they using reverse 911 and the Emergency Broadcast System, which includes push alerts to phones? We have technology to warn everyone directly without using Meta or Musk. It would never occur to me to seek such information on social media. (1/2)

As a child of the 90s, I had many a sick day Price is Right interrupted by EBS tests. They've indoctrinated me into checking reliable sources In case of real emergencies. ::buzz buzz:: (2/2)

I hate that we have all the IPAWS and related infrastructure at the national level and regional govs still use social media for the authoritative messages.

Sure, but for better or worse there are solutions to that particular problem. Forcing people into a privately owned service is IMO so much worse.

thinking about this more, on a practical level how hard would be to have a universal address for whatever state you're in, so michigan for example, "MIemergency.gov", where county/city/local officials post updates the same time they do on twitter or facebook, and you just have to enter your zipcode?

or... do something statewide that is updated in real time from different agencies, and has a funky website. you can give it a bounding box for alerts near your home. also if you allow it, it'll tell you if anything is happening near you. it. is. bloody. awesome! emergency.vic.gov.au/respond/

emergency.vic.gov.auIncidents and Warnings - VicEmergencyVictoria's combined source of emergency information and warnings, helping the community to prepare for, respond to and recover from emergencies across the state.

It's not a real emergency information system unless anybody who's got access to a device can see the posts. And if the rich "genius" guy in charge can't explain how this can be enabled for official accounts, and make it happen -- he's no genius!

THIS IS WHY HE BOUGHT TWITTER. It has always been the water cooler for journalists. So all the businesses and gov accounts thought they had to be there…because that’s where journalists are. He trapped the media ecosystem. It’s wild more people don’t talk about this.

This by the why is the justification Biden and the Ds should have used to block Musk's takeover of Twitter. As many official government and emergency accounts are on Twitter it's insane to allow a takeover backed by hostile foreign investors.

In days gone by, local govt tv programming required a cable tv subscription to view. Tech changes, govt use of it doesn't. Publishing public content on non public channels is really idiotic.

“This is not precautionary. … This thing is going to fail, and we don’t know when,” said Garden Grove Fire Chief Craig Covey during a Friday afternoon press conference. “We’re doing our best to figure out when or how we can prevent it.”

This would be a good a job for the USPS. Users could register physical addresses and mobile numbers. Local governments, state EMA's, and FEMA could push notices based on registered addresses. Would also be a good mechanism for password recovery.

feeling like a youtuber doing an ad read, but squarespace is right there. neocities? wordpress? github pages? hell just drop a NOAA-style update in a pastebin the whole point of the web was the open publishing and access

sigh. it would be boring and annoying but probably possible to get each city set up with a bluesky account that mirrors on their websites. It would maybe be plausible to get the county to set up a PDS so the system is evergreen regardless of bsky continuance. organizing it would be annoying, but...