Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ

@carlysmith.net

Writer, freelance light novel/manga editor. ๐ŸŒˆ She/her. ๐Ÿ“– Editor for The Tiny Witch from the Deep Woods, Reborn to Master the Blade, My Magical Career at Court, I'm a Terminal Cancer Patient, and more! https://www.carlysmith.net/

494 followers207 following392 posts

Pinned

Hi all! I figured it's time to do an introduction post. I'm a freelance editor. You may have seen my work in things like Qualia the Purple, Otonari Complex, The Magical Revolution of the Reincarnated Princess and the Genius Young Lady, and Reborn to Master the Blade, to name a few. ใ‚ˆใ‚ใ—ใใŠ้ก˜ใ„ใ—ใพใ™ ๐Ÿ™‡

Whenever I see someone try to point out that AI is just a tool for efficiency and they try to compare that to a spellchecker or something that quickly lets you search for something in a document (like a reg ex find and replace), I have to remind myself that they're probably arguing in bad faith.

View full thread

I think at the end of the day, it's a classic consideration of needing to ask ourselves is a tool we're using making the decisions for us, or are we molding ourselves around the tool? Who is it serving? Who does generative AI really benefit? Seems like all it does is encourage slop.

Whenever I see someone try to point out that AI is just a tool for efficiency and they try to compare that to a spellchecker or something that quickly lets you search for something in a document (like a reg ex find and replace), I have to remind myself that they're probably arguing in bad faith.

View full thread

The tools I use help me find things faster, and then I can evaluate each instance to see if something like "lie vs. lay" was used correctly in the sentence. Everything is contextual, and *if you know your stuff,* you will always be better than a machine.

It's the same thing I see used in some medical contexts. I know there are some models out there that can more quickly flag issues in something like a brain scan (and they'll have more false positives) to which they draw attention for a radiologist to further interpret.

Whenever I see someone try to point out that AI is just a tool for efficiency and they try to compare that to a spellchecker or something that quickly lets you search for something in a document (like a reg ex find and replace), I have to remind myself that they're probably arguing in bad faith.

It is not worth it to argue with them, because they went to their conclusion first and are working backward from there to find their reasoning to convince themselves that their usage of AI for writing or editing is okay. The tools we're using for more precise searches aren't making the decisions.

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

when someone is revealed to have done racist things or behaved in a racist way, actively, responding โ€œthat person is not A Racistโ€ isnโ€™t appropriate. racism is something you do. if you think of people as โ€œa racistโ€ or โ€œnot a racistโ€, you donโ€™t actually know what youโ€™re talking about. itโ€™s a tell.

There are aspects of Anime NYC I really enjoy. A lot of my favorite artists attend, it's local to me so I don't need a hotel, a lot of colleagues attend so I can catch up with people and network with people new to me... but man, it has felt overwhelmingly more corporate every single year.

I missed it this year due to being ill, and I'll likely still go next year assuming I continue to get a pro badge, but it's become a con I don't actually recommend a lot of people attend unless they're going for work and/or local.

It feels weird that there was celebration of Manga Million--a project where Shueisha is trying to spend as little money as possible to get translations of manga--at an awards ceremony celebrating the work of translators and everyone working on manga...

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

You missed the funniest part of the tweet

William Lawrence@wewill2026.bsky.social

This is what data center developers are saying all across Michigan It's condescending and it's going over like a lead balloon.ย  Michiganders don't need some California billionaires telling us what to do, and we aren't buying their false promises.

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

OUT NOW from J-Novel Club: "Mirror, Mirror on the Wall" Actor-turned-idol Eiri has spent more than a decade hiding his feelings for genius photographer Shoui. But when Shoui replaces him with a new muse, Eiri must finally face his worst fearsโ€ฆ bit.ly/4xdSBR8

This is my latest editing project for J-Novel! I love getting to work on BL that features adult characters, so this was a delight.

TheOASG@theoasg.mastodon.social.ap.brid.gy

J-Novel Club has announced at Anime NYC that theyโ€™ve licensed for their J-Novel Knight imprint Daizu Konaka & Ryou Mizukaneโ€™s Mirror, Mirror on the Wall: Who Ate the Poisoned Apple, Core and All?

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

This industry, these awards, these conventions would not exist without the underpaid freelancers working 80-hour weeks, and I have deep respect for Jan using her moment in the spotlight to call out the poor working conditions that her and her colleagues are subjected to

This post is unavailable.

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

LRT: thereโ€™s a reason everyone who works in Japanese media localization is rallying around Janโ€™s statement here. Anime, manga, and games are seemingly bigger than ever and none of the creatives involved in getting that media into English are making any money.

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

So, How Does The Green Work, Anyway??? Working on the lettering (English text) for The Guy She Was Interested Wasnโ€™t A Guy At All has been an interesting experience. I primarily work in black and white manga, or on rare occasions, full color.

I wanted to go to the Manga Awards so badly this year, primarily to cheer on Tiina, who has been pushing herself so hard forever, but particularly when starting at Kana. The Billy Bat license was an amazing grab, and she's worked hard on it (as has the whole team!)

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

I have huge admiration for Jan for using this opportunity to speak up for all freelancers. This award is richly deserved on so many levels. Congratulations and thanks to her.

This post is unavailable.

Jan is one of the best, and even better--the courage to tell clients to their faces in-person that they owe us better! Manga and light novels are some of the worst paid gigs, and sometimes it takes us 2 months to even get paid.

This post is unavailable.

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

Are YOU going to the anime convention blessed by Mamdani?

Anime NYC@animenyc.bsky.social

My convention's anime My tastes are weeb WE GOT A LETTER FROM MAMDANI CAN YOU BELIEVE We are honored to have received this welcome letter from @nycmayor! Anime NYC starts TODAY!

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

I 100% have not changed a single goddamn thing about how I write here in the age of "AI." I write how I write. If the "AI" writes anything like how I write, it's because it stole from me. I'm gonna use any punctuation I like, and if it looks "AI"ish to you, you can go fuck yourself.

Manisha Krishnan@manishakrishnan.bsky.social

Authors and journalists are doing more first-person (hello 2010s blogging) and embracing "mistakes" in writing to prove they're not chatbots. There's even an โ€œanti-Grammarly" app that leaves in typos and signs off "sent from my iPhone" to create more authenticity: www.wired.com/story/more-t...

Carly Smith ๐Ÿ“–โœ๏ธ reposted

cashier today told me he knew me from twitter and said him and his partner still use โ€œthe butterโ€™s penthouseโ€ ๐Ÿ˜ญ