Dr Brett H Meyer

Dr Brett H Meyer

@bretthmeyer.bsky.social

We live because everything else does. —Richard Wagamese He/him, Professor of ECE, researching hardware-software co-design of machine learning systems; 🇺🇸 in 🇨🇦! Views expressed are my own. https://rssl.ece.mcgill.ca/

451 followers644 following366 posts

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

Anthropic is out with new nonsense about Claude (or the collection of models called Claude) deserving moral consideration and/or be able to feel distress, so my inbox is filling up with journos asking me to comment. I've also got a day job, so here is a brief set of public comments on this: >>

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

Forget Columbus Day (US) or Thanksgiving Day (Canada). It should be Indigenous Peoples' Day across Turtle Island. Celebrate Indigenous strength, resilience, and culture today instead of romanticizing settler history.

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

Whenever someone legitimizes harmful shit with the importance of achieving "dominance" you have a fascist at hand.

This post is unavailable.

Oof, this makes me feel ill. It’s epistimicide on an unfathomable scale, and we’re being led into it to the joyful beating of the drums of “progress.”

This post is unavailable.

Resist the uncritical adoption of AI in education. openletter.earth/open-letter-...

openletter.earthOpen Letter: Stop the Uncritical Adoption of AI Technologies in Academia
Mar Hicks@histoftech.bsky.social

They’ll keep telling us it’s inevitable but NYC and other large school systems are starting to say no to AI, recognizing it’s not a legitimate tool for k-12 learning. Even some universities are putting their foot down, like U Chicago (and some law schools) www.nyc.gov/mayors-offic...

This is about what I would expect. GenAI is a B or C student. For my part, this is driving a move away from graded homework and toward exams that test practical skills in a controlled environment.

DGM@notredale.bsky.social

Here is the full chart with labeled axes. It is comparing homework scores to test scores. Below-average and average scorers for homework and exams appear at about the same frequency regardless of AI usage. The high homework scorers using AI, however, are not replicating that success at test time.

Can you be a billionaire without also being a solipsist?

Amanda Marcotte@amandamarcotte.bsky.social

Yup. When Musk says "no one" died, he's asserting that people of color are not people. Not that fact-checking is useless. But it needs to be paired with reminders that Musk is a racist who is asserting that non-white people aren't people. newrepublic.com/article/2135...

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

Is something “too dangerous” if it’s easy to slap on guardrails? Tigers are really dangerous. Tigers are at the zoo in my town. Don’t go in the tiger enclosure at the zoo. The zoo is pretty good at keeping you out. Under normal circumstances, tigers aren’t really something to be alarmed about.

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

Welcome to the Slopocene Epoch.

Timothy Caulfield@caulfieldtim.bsky.social

Our A.I. world! 👇 More books, more scientific papers, more music... all created by A.I. Much of this is slop, polluting & confusing our information environment and making it more difficult to find quality content. wapo.st/4dncIVu via @washingtonpost.com

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

Particularly in the context of (appropriate) crackdowns on LLM-generated papers (e.g., on arXiv) and more and more tales of fabricated citations, two reminders: (1) LLMs do not "cite their sources" (2) Using an LLM to generate, complete, or fix LaTeX code can result in fabricated citations

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

I desire more in life than to be the “don’t summarise with AI”-guy on bluesky 😅 but reports like this keep coming in, so I’ll repeat ad nauseam, don’t summarise with ‘AI’! www.tue.nl/en/our-unive...

tue.nlAre AI-generated summaries suitable for studying and research?Author: Maarten Paulusse Despite didactic, ethical, and environmental concerns, the use of GenAI is on the rise in academia. For most applications, the jury is still out on whether and how they will b...
Ars Technica@arstechnica.com

The fact that the Ontario government recommended AI summary systems with such obvious and potentially patient-harming flaws should give pause to any doctors (or their patients) making use of them.

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

"I have a finite time on this earth that I mostly want to spend interacting with other human beings. I don’t want to be the person arguing with a robot, or wasting my time reading something that a real person couldn’t be bothered to write."

Jason Koebler@jasonkoebler.bsky.social

I wrote about being inundated with AI writing at every turn, unwittingly turning my brain into the AI police, and how shitty AI writing is randomly showing up in my real life outside of the internet www.404media.co/your-ai-use-...

Writing is “a way of learning what one thinks by attempting to say it. An LLM can reproduce the appearance of that activity, but it can’t replace it, because the value lies not only in the object produced but in the transformation that occurs during its making.” www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-i...

theguardian.comI knew my writing students were using AI. Their confessions led to a powerful teaching moment | Micah NathanThe problem wasn’t just the perfectly polished, yet mediocre prose. It’s what’s lost when we surrender the struggle to translate thought into words

“High-volume, on-deadline reviewing, [Orwell] argues [in Confessions of a Book Reviewer, does not merely deform the work of reading – it deforms the self. The mindless manufacture of responses erodes judgment, and standards collapse.” Oof. There’s an scathing indictment of present day peer review.

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

Replying to @carlbergstrom.com

The National Science Foundation is the main source of funding for basic sciences in the US. For decades, they have supported a scientific R&D ecosystem in the US that has been an engine of economic growth and competitive advantage. Destroying the agency is no less than an act of sabotage.

Just imagine installing an OS and needing to acknowledge that “the software is not intended for use in California” because it does not comply with their age verification law. 🫠

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

"What exactly do you expect Carney to do / not do?" A thread of 50 specific items (with links, and not in any particular order), a large fraction of which are in line with warning signs we pointed out early on and were told to be quiet, wait and see, or trust his 4D chess acumen. 1/??

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

“Amazon, Microsoft & Google ​have each recently abandoned construction of multibillion-dollar data centers over community opposition & now the companies are coming under shareholder pressure over ‌the environmental impact” Lose the passive voice—PEOPLE are doing this💫 www.reuters.com/sustainabili...

reuters.comInvestors press Amazon, Microsoft and Google on water, power use in US data centersAmazon, Microsoft and Alphabet's Google ​have each recently abandoned construction of multibillion-dollar data centers over community opposition and now the companies are coming under shareholder pres...

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

Replying to @astrokatie.com

I certainly won't claim that all human scientific endeavors have always been good and noble and without any suffering to humankind. But I will say that the scientific impulse--the curiosity that drives us to work together to understand our universe--is one of my very favorite things about humanity.

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

I met with AI data labelers in Kenya who are organizing their colleagues to fight the brutal working conditions and horrible pay given to the workers at the "bottom of the AI supply chain." They believe the NDAs they've signed are unenforceable so are speaking out: www.404media.co/ai-is-africa...

404media.co'AI Is African Intelligence': The Workers Who Train AI Are Fighting BackKenyan workers are still the underpaid labor behind AI training, moderation, and sex chatbots. The Data Labelers Association is fighting back.

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

Category error! I'm sick to the back teeth of comparisons to humans. It's so rife even colleagues do it. What's next? > I compared a rock and a person, and challenged them to stay still the longest and the rock won! Wow! Things thought up by the unhinged & those who wish to dehumanise for profit.

Community *is* the most important part. Don’t let corporations profit from driving us into isolation.

Daniel José Older@djolder.bsky.social

Common thread in all the things wrong with genAI use across industries is that genAI is fundamentally anti-community and community is the most important part of any discipline, tradition, craft, study.

Oof, yes: magical thinking and self-soothing for sure.

Jeff Sharlet@jeffsharlet.bsky.social

Too many “middle ground” AI arguments—“I have concerns, too, but we have to adapt”—proceed from what is to me a peculiar embrace of “inevitability” which seems to be magical thinking, a way of depoliticizing the political, of self-soothing in the face of an overwhelming challenge.

The grey goo that we used to be afraid of, the output of out of control nano machines? It’s actually this. It isn’t a sterile organic landscape, it’s an unsympathetically incongruent, incomprehensible, and untrustworthy information landscape.

Emily M. Bender@emilymbender.bsky.social

And you can build and use language models without turning them into the synthetic text extruding machines that are despoiling our information ecosystem. >>

This is the way.

Emily M. Bender@emilymbender.bsky.social

What we argued in Stochastic Parrots, however, was that you can get those benefits of the transformer architecture without ammassing datasets too large to collect with care (meaning consentfully, intentionally, and with the ability to document what's in the data). >>

Yes, they are harmful— especially in education— precisely because of their utility.

Benjamin Riley@benjaminjriley.bsky.social

Actually, stochastic parrots...are good! At least as a metaphor for large-language models, and there's no reason to deny their usefulness. Rather the opposite: They are harmful precisely because of their utility. Also included, a face-biting parrot named Chiku. I really enjoyed writing this one.

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

“If you look at major companies and corporations like Microsoft and Google, they are the very entities that are powering genocide, powering war. You start to realize that a lot of the claims around 'AI for good' start to crumble.” - @abeba.bsky.social

And not only completing it, but doing so well, producing a durable result worth being proud of. There has always been shortcuts. When the work matters, they’re always a trap.

Eryk Salvaggio@eryk.bsky.social

I understand why people like LLMs because I, too, really want this paper to be done. By which I mean, I want to “stop thinking about it,” but to do so I have to arrive at a point where the thought is *complete* rather than the point at which I am “frustrated by the challenge of completing it.”

Dr Brett H Meyer reposted

Rhetoric didn’t shoot the guns.

Aaron Rupar@atrupar.com

Homan: "I begged for the last two months on TV for the rhetoric to stop. I said in March -- if the rhetoric doesn't stop, there is gonna be bloodshed. And there has been. I wish I wasn't right. I don't want to see anybody die."