Post

Sad but let’s be honest - reading to your kid is not inherently ‘enjoyable’ because it’s a simple, boring child’s book (at least to me) but as the parent I have to make it fun. Add a little jazz. To make it less boring parents can focus on the kid’s joy and less on the ‘boringness’ of the book. 😬

Glad someone else said it. If I have to read three little pigs one more time, I am going to scream. Doing voices was fun a few months ago and she is still is on this book. My oldest was the same way as a toddler. Actually tonight I will give the pigs a deep voice and the wolf will sound like a pig

Everybody has their own taste of course, but speaking as a librarian who purchases kids books & one who has been reading to my kid for about a decade, I have mostly found books for kids that I love too. If you're having this experience with kids books, I believe your local librarian could help. :-)

There are so many really good children’s books though, even on the lowest reading levels! I absolutely loved reading the Elephant and Piggie books to my kid. They were hilarious. My kid and I still occasionally quote the line “Know how I get that old shoe taste? Old shoes!” to each other.

Yep. I think these sad numbers are a symptom of parents just focusing on their own enjoyment/pleasure instead of their children’s 😒 It really wouldn’t kill to read at least ONE book a day and no one watches PBS or other broadcasting which used to remind the public about the importance of reading.💔

Sandra Boynton has a TON of books that are fun to read, and our baby (who just turned 1) has loved many of them. She's currently very into Dinosaur Dance. Mothman Baby (diff author) has also remained a hit basically her whole life.

This is absolutely wild to me. I *loved* reading to my kids. And now, my eldest, *loves* reading to her child. Some of the best parenting memories ... goodness, people are really missing out.

I'm sure screens have something to do with it, but also I think there is A LOT of newer kid lit that is horribly written. I have read so many books with no plot, boring language, clearly written with an agenda of Learning...leaving me wondering if the author has ever met or been a child.

Were there nights when I was tired, and it was a chore? Hell yes. Did I do it anyway? Goddamn right. Was it fun and rewarding, and do I look back on it fondly? Fuckin' A. Did it inspire a lifelong love of reading in my son? No, goddammit! Where did I go wrong?

At least in England they realized that the so-called "Science of Reading" is a hoax perpetrated by private equity. Here in the US it's going full steam ahead based on the lies of a podcaster

Curious what you consider "lies." I assume you are referring to Hanford. I've been teaching reading since 2003, and her reporting matches up with my experience pf the field - and the experiences of so many other teachers I know.

She never even TRIED to explain why fourth grade reading AND fourth grade math showed increases in standardized test scores (maybe because you ran the lowest scoring through third grade again??) BUT all gains are GONE by eighth grade! Why do you think that is??

Yeah I felt a lot less guilty about the Cocomelon and Blippi when my son suddenly started reading at a 1st grade level before kindergarten. He had been resisting trying to sound out words but we did a book every night, and then suddenly things clicked and he became a voracious reader.

Do you all watch Number Blocks? It’s the most fun and educational math program ever made. My 8 year old is now a dedicated reader after reading to him from the beginning. We still read to him every night. This article is a huge bummer. How is it not fun to read to your kid?

In my experience it’s more “why are we reading this one AGAIN, is 10 times in one night not enough?” as I shred my larynx reading “The Book With No Pictures” by BJ Novak with gusto. Legit almost lost my voice from that one over a weekend.

I don’t have kids but I feel like some of the ‘how could you not love it’ have never read to a toddler who wanted the same book every time and constantly moved the pages around so you couldn’t actually get through it 🤦🏻‍♀️

I think I'm probably pretty bad at the Scottish accents, but I try to mitigate it by going with different voices - deep voices, scratchy voices, high voices, nasal voices - when we are doing the Nac Mac Feegles. It helps that the kids are really forgiving about it, too.

Reading to my 4 yr old son every night before bed is something we both look forward to every day. Two books a night, every night, since they day he was born. He loves going to the library too 🥹

Does anyone have a link to the study results? If this is Harper Collins UK, are these UK findings? Putting in a plug for US data, the now-shuttered Nat’l Ctr for Education Statistics has been collecting data on home literacy activities for decades. The Trump administration has wiped this out.

Part of it is some boys can’t sit still as well (whether the reasons are cultural or gender-based doesn’t matter) but it’s equally valuable to read to a toddler while he moves around a room.

Something I've been hung up on recently is that we have all of this fretting about how young men are poorly socialized, not succeeding, becoming reactionary, etc. and there's all these grand ideas about how to save them, but I feel like we actively avoid looking at parenting as the direct issue

I think there's a widespread belief that we've tried progressive/feminist childrearing and it somehow failed or resulted in boys being left behind, but I think that's pretty clearly not true. Feminism includes treating boys as capable & deserving of love, affection, care, and respect

It was never true. The reason why there’s a crisis of male loneliness these days is that feminism was able to change the standard for women (not entirely of course), but not for men when it comes to expectations in society. So same expectations for men exist in a more egalitarian society.

Paula, I hope you will follow @defenseofdemocracy.bsky.social & www.defenseofdemocracy.org as we're a volunteer-run org protecting inclusive public schools and fighting Moms for Liberty and assorted fascists who whitewash history curricula and ban books ‼️ We'd love to have your voice ‼️❤️✊📚📖📕📗📘📙📔

defenseofdemocracy.orgHOME - DEFENSE OF DEMOCRACYDefense of Democracy educates the public about the importance of the public school and library systems in a functioning democracy by and providing training, tools, and coordination for communities acr...

WHAT!?! Why? Reading to our daughter is one of my most joyful experiences of her childhood. We read to her every night until 8th grade when she decided she wanted to read on her own. She's currently 23 and in graduate school for engineering.

How can you not enjoy reading to your kids! There your child is, at 5, 6,7 having no idea that Daddy is hamming it up under the secret impression that if only things had gone a little differently, he'd absolutely be starring in the next Olivier theater production of The Tempest.

Its a small pity that the R word was weaponised as a slur for disability, because these kids are being intentionally slowed, restrained, and held back in every way. Nimble fingers and brains like pool balls.

i bet a number of them would love to love reading to their children, but struggle to engage them more than the slop content machine does, and everyone is worse off for it

It’s so disturbing when I see nanny’s doing that. I get it maybe at restaurants but the rest of the time?!? Can’t imagine doing bed time without reading to my kid.

Our daughter in her nine years has used the phone at a restaurant literally twice. I’m very proud that we resisted that as a solution to crankiness. It helps that we started bringing her so early in her life and was thankfully chill.

I read to my son in the womb every night. He was reading well before school and in grade 3* helped with remedial reading for grades 1 and 2. *And throughout his schooling. In grade 9, he was helping the teacher with Shakespeare, being he had read much of our 2000 book library and all of his works.

A big part of this is how viscerally angry other people get if they have to hear a child existing in public. Parents feel shamed to do whatever it takes to make sure children don’t act like children if there’s a stranger in ear shot.

I am unfortunately related to someone (extremely intelligent, high earner) who used to start a meal by plopping an iPad in front of the kid, in addition to other choice parenting habits. I’m happy that I don’t know if that still happens because I haven’t seen that fool in years.

Why nightmarish? I'm all in favor of spending-time-as-a-family moments, but tbh mealtimes were rarely in that category for my household (connecting to each other while eating just never worked for us). Before smartphones & tablets, we'd bring books to read.

yep. and it starts early too. when my son was about six months my dad tried to give him an ipad to play with and i basically had to pull a stern “don’t do that again” with him.

The most we do is a little kids laptop with keyboard that does letter and numbers and sometimes using the iPad for drawing on notepad. And our kid can entertain herself on drives, walks and has an imagination. No screens as parental replacement.

despite my high levels of brainrot we basically don't have screens around when the kids are home, and they mostly entertain themselves with blocks and toys and art and the like

The effects seem ruinous. I keep finding that one major indicator for uncontrolled / destructive behavior among elementary school age playmates is whether they know who Mr. Beast is

There is some interesting information in the article about why parents read less to children: the increase in the idea that it's a skill instead of a pleasant activity, increase in schoolwork displacing time for reading, and parents having less time for reading.

I think it's easy to blame smart phone and iPads for the reduction in reading, but it oversimplifies the problem and ignores the way school specifically and education generally have turned into basically full time jobs for children, where every output is measured, weighed, rewarded and punished.

Not unrelated to the death of civic virtue. Your first and most immediate civic duty is to raise your kids the best you can. If you’re too lazy to do that…

One benefit of kids learning to read that I didn't quite expect is that you can do this with kindles pretty easily, always bring them with you and kids can do it independently wherever. But they don't get riled up like they do if they're watching a video or playing a video game.

See also: audiobooks Not necessarily arguing against reading aloud yourself to children, but if for whatever reason you can't or don't want to, there are better alternatives than LCD screens

I read to my son every night for years. By 12 years old, he was reading and writing at a college level. It’s one of the best things you can do intellectually for your child and helps solidify the parent/child bond and trust.

My parents read to me pretty much every night until I was old enough to read myself. Then it became them telling me to *stop* reading and go to bed 😁 Reading is so incredibly important for childhood development, a ton of studies say this

I still read to my adult child sometimes. My grandfather read my grandmother a bedtime story when she was too old to read. This should be a regular thing for all ages.

Wow, that is sad. Reading to my kids when they were young was one of the great experiences of my life, and I would give nearly anything to be able to do it again

Unfortunately, modern people are so retarded that we need public advertising campaigns to remind them of the importance of fundamental things such as reading stories to your child, and joining sporting clubs to foster a sense of connectedness

people should read to their kids. I dont think shaming parents about using phones/tablets is effective. Public spaces are not kid friendly, the access/affordability of childcare is shit, etc. Parents giving kids tablets in public for 15min is not this grave sin you want to make it out to be.

I'm with you on this. I agree that kids not being read to as much is an issue we should be discussing, but the "shame parents for ever letting their kids use a tablet/phone" schtick gets really tired. Complex reasons for what ppl are doing and why, always.

There's all sorts of other things it could be like singing to them, creating stories together, creative ways of talking out the day or playing with games or toys, etc. But quality time together in a quiet reflective space seems really key and reading works very well in that slot!

All those things happen while you are reading. The reading is a pretense for sitting still. And the reading has an end point. End of chapter, end of book, end of two books. I just can’t imagine negotiating the end of the night without the routine of a book. THE END. How bout the end of the day.

Yeah, even if they're a selfish parent that doesn't want to do it because it's good for their kid, it's still a great way to get them into a routine to sleep at night.

Right? I have no idea. There was a point when my youngest felt he was outgrowing story time before bed, so we switched up to playing a board game or card game on his bed before lights out. But he needed that quiet one-on-one time to settle down for sleep. What do parents today do?

Yep, my mom started what we called "Talk Time" after we hit ages where we could read ourselves just fine (pretty young due in large part to how often we were read to) - which was my mom making our stuffed animals move around and talk to us. A great way to process the events and feelings of the day.

Parents shouldn't have children if they don't want to assume responsibility for raising thoughtful, educated human beings ‼️That's how we got MAGATS. As children these people were allowed to remain ignorant. Ignorance does not equal bliss. Ignorance creates fear of the other and encourages hatred‼️🔥

We started reading to our kid at bedtime when she was 1 month old, mostly to train US for a bedtime routine. She’s almost 8 and we still do it. I’d rather read to her for hours than do 5 minutes of pretend play!

I think a question to consider is if we are allowing time for the promotion of joyful reading in school, in society? Modeled read-alouds to the Gen-Z group and their children now are poo-pooped in order to make more room for standardized test prep, and

even reading for “leisure” is often measured on a competitive basis, with computer quizzes to check for comprehension. At later grades, novel/play units have been phased out in favor of…more test prep! Again, where is the joy? What examples were parents given?

Story time is so much more than the story. It’s the cuddles, the silliness, the conversations and the imaginings. To the young parents out there…you’re going to blink and your little ones will be standing in front of you in a cap & gown.

As a single parent of 4 children, my mom didn't have time to read to us after the divorce. BUT she had instilled in us that reading was fun prior to that & we all continued to love to read.

Oh man - so sad - how the hell do you check on their emerging literacy skills if you don’t read together - helping them with the decoding, checking for comprehension, sharing emotional responses to what is going on in the story - crucial for parents to model what fluent readers do. With voices!

I’m a youth librarian. I see this trend where once kids start to read independently the parents stop reading picture books to them and switch to easy readers read by themselves. Easy readers by design have very simple vocab and plot. Kids need a mix of both to keep them interested.

No discussion of the structural reasons, just cultural ones, as usual. But I get it. I'm Gen X and I wanted my kids to experience the great books I read as a kid. If Z and beyond weren't read to, they don't have a repertoire of nostalgic favorites, maybe just TV shows.

They did discuss increased homework as one structural reason for this within older children. It also doesn’t seem that the percent of parents who wish they had more time to spend reading to their kids has changed since they don’t note change from 2012 in that figure.

I meant more that parents both have to work, sometimes two jobs, or doing gig economy, to afford basic things these days. Ppl can't afford to live close to work, so more ppl commute, giving less time at home, etc.

This data is from the UK and comparing 2012 to 2024. While people in the UK aren’t doing great economically currently, they also weren’t doing well in 2012 either. And, when compared to 1998, few work additional jobs or even work additional hours (as of 2019, since in 2022 data is impacted by COVID)

I completely get that parents are beyond exhausted or crunched for time (or both, * raises hand *) but reading to my kid is non-negotiable. Kids are DYING to connect w/ their parents. Especially at bedtime when they may be anxious knowing they are about to be alone for the longest stretch of the day

Well I'm 38 and I'm of the generation where reading dropoff started really increasing, so if parents aren't reading for their own pleasure of course they aren't for their children

By the way, the key window for helping kids with their early language development is between 18 and 24 months. Reading to them is great, but also just having tons of conversational back and forth turn taking!

My little one would not allow it. She wants me to read to her at least 5 times a day. And I still read to my eldest almost every night. How do they expect their kids to become proper grown-ups without reading to them? Oh yeah, AI will do everything for them right? Terrifying thought

Reading to older kids can be fun, but I totally get this. 0-4 year olds want to read the same books over and over again. I like Lowly Worm as much as the next dad, but I can only try to find him at the airport so many times.

That's a shame - I read to my son every night - he started reading on his own when he was 3. He and his wife read to their daughter every night, and at age 7, she is now reading on a 3rd grade level. Reading to your child is truly one of the most important things you can do as a parent.

By the time we stopped when they were 10 & 12 I’d read the entire Harry Potter & Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy books, countless Captain Underpants and Dog Man’s and so much more. Reading together is genuinely one of the best parts of having small kids!

That’s fucking crazy, reading to my kids was one of the funnest routines of parenting when my kids were little, I was reminiscing with them, now both in high school, about reading Richard Scarry’s Cars & Trucks and Things That Go to them a million times just the other day

That's so sad. Children's books can be really good, too, with excellent stories & illustrations. There were times when I was as interested in the story as the child listener I was reading to.