Chris Giles

Chris Giles

@chrisgiles.ft.com

Economics Commentator, Financial Times; Honorary Professor of Practice, UCL Policy Lab “Media wing of the Treasury/OBR complex” Truss (2026) My central banks newsletter https://ep.ft.com/newsletters/subscribe?newsletterIds=6501cc9ec6e3c91c18b0b9e6

27.7K followers427 following1.1K posts

Chris Giles reposted

New Liz Truss book doesn't disappoint. Thrust is blaming the Bank of England for the Sept 2022 market fallout, especially its quantitative tightening announcement the day before the mini-budget. She claims that she and Kwarteng were "caught off-guard", blindsided by the BoE's announcement.

Caught red handed I expected more of someone who used to follow me on Twitter

Andy Bruce (Reuters)@bruceandy.bsky.social

Apologies to @dsmitheconomics.bsky.social, @chrisgiles.ft.com and @edconway.bsky.social - I'm afraid Liz Truss is on to you. In the next paragraph she goes on to praise the free-thinking Patrick Minford.

Maybe read the 1 September notice before posting. The £80bn figure is there along with a 12 month timescale. Full schedule not there, true, but that was not Truss’s allegation

This post is unavailable.

This is very good

Tony Tassell@tonytassell.bsky.social

in which @bhgreeley.bsky.social takes aim at tokensation, arguing why it does not suspend the laws of finance as.ft.com/r/fb0b5d8a-a...

The only interesting thing about the 22 Sept meeting was the interest rate decision. 0.5pp rise. We wrote a long piece on it in the FT and didn’t really mention QT (because it had already been announced) as.ft.com/r/613f638d-8... Bank of England lifts interest rates by 0.5 percentage points

as.ft.comBank of England lifts interest rates by 0.5 percentage pointsUK rate-setters hold back from matching global peers’ more aggressive increases but hint at large rise in November

France is burning; the US doesn’t promise prudence and still borrows more than expected: Italy has a chronic debt problem. So I asked which G7 country is the profligacy poster child (Extensive use of 🦔 charts - the king of charts) as.ft.com/r/85dfdf71-3...

For all the chart pedants in my timeline.... ... I also like this chart and it is one I did myself (the FT calculations in the footer are quite extensive)

Chris Giles@chrisgiles.ft.com

You should never argue with a price, but.... The European (EU and UK) gas crisis that has tripled prices this year is not that bad... Storage is at normal levels relative to consumption. So much other evidence in my piece www.ft.com/content/31df...

Oh FFS We went through this years ago. Maybe British nationals are retiring so this is isn’t surprising.

Roland Smith@rolandmcs.bsky.social

'They're taking all our jobs', @jdportes.bsky.social

Interesting lack of Green Party presence at a polling station in Holborn &St Pancras this morning. Clearly they haven’t got much of a ground game, despite the deluge of leaflets

I was once asked to go into the OBR and discuss the EFO. They thought I was being provocative saying it needed to be slimmed by 80% I was being serious

Duncan Weldon@duncanweldon.bsky.social

There is a debate worth having about the length and detail of OBR reports. Compare a 2010 OBR report to a 2026 OBR report and you see a really big difference.

Chris Giles reposted

Sensible advice as ever from @chrisgiles.ft.com, particularly to the OBR to focus on fiscal sustainability rather than "fiscal headroom". Too much time is wasted on second guessing the OBR. The Chancellor's time is better spent focusing on the fiscal substance.

I’ve had this original Steve Bell cartoon on my wall for almost 30 years… … hadn’t realised how ironically wrong it is until now

Central banks always think interest rate rates operate on demand. But what if tighter policy makes people want to work more? That labour supply effect can be large. People with high debts worked more when Australia tightened, for example My newsletter: www.ft.com/content/a060...

Important to note that ONS is now doing the right thing and trying to find the truth. This is nothing like the 2010s when it actively sought not to change stats (RPI) that it knew were wrong

Chris Giles@chrisgiles.ft.com

After the ONS cast all my article about the UK productivity puzzle onto the scrap heap, it has now downgraded all articles on the UK’s weak jobs recovery after Covid to junk too…. 😖 www.ons.gov.uk/employmentan...

Was it though? Sounds awfully like the bores of Piddington

Duncan Weldon@duncanweldon.bsky.social

I miss the old days when a disgruntled noble in a dispute with the crown would just spent a few years sulking in the Low Countries before landing at a fishing village in the south west with some Flemish mercenaries and heading for the Welsh Marches to raise his banner. Much more dignified.

Chris Giles reposted

Continuation of a long-term trend

Xiaowei Xu@xiaoweixu.bsky.social

Guys we've got a new puzzle: why have hours fallen so much? Based on ONS's new approach, average hours worked are down 5% since 2007 (before the financial crisis), 2% since pre-Covid.

Chris Giles reposted

And on 1), the fact that it was the prior intention means it's important to follow through, absent some v good reason, to avoid validating the suspicion that QE was a permanent monetary financing.

Chris Giles@chrisgiles.ft.com

The BoE, HMT, DMO decision to unwind quantatitive easing completely is NOT something to get worked up by, however tempting. 1) This was always the intention (see Mervyn King 2009) 2) It has tiny fiscal effects (nothing like George Osborne's 2012 gambit, which ONS stopped after my complaints).

The BoE, HMT, DMO decision to unwind quantatitive easing completely is NOT something to get worked up by, however tempting. 1) This was always the intention (see Mervyn King 2009) 2) It has tiny fiscal effects (nothing like George Osborne's 2012 gambit, which ONS stopped after my complaints).

View full thread

7) UK gilt market likes it - but let's not get too excited by a 10bp move in the 30-year yield. That way madness lies 8) The pause in sales until April suggests that despite working on this for a year and despite many outsiders suggesting similar stuff, UK authorities can't take decisions quickly

The BoE, HMT, DMO decision to unwind quantatitive easing completely is NOT something to get worked up by, however tempting. 1) This was always the intention (see Mervyn King 2009) 2) It has tiny fiscal effects (nothing like George Osborne's 2012 gambit, which ONS stopped after my complaints).

View full thread

4) Having DMO do sales to the market is also marginal. It always set the marturity structure of issuance after knowing the BoE sales, so was always in charge. This formallises the practice 5) There is a tiny benefit to the public purse from BoE not selling small quantities of illiquid bonds

6) Governments of any colour could still work with BoE on a tiered reserves scheme not to remunerate all reserves at Bank Rate if a future government wanted to (at least untile 2034). But BoE by continuing QT is reducing the interest rate risk it bears

The BoE, HMT, DMO decision to unwind quantatitive easing completely is NOT something to get worked up by, however tempting. 1) This was always the intention (see Mervyn King 2009) 2) It has tiny fiscal effects (nothing like George Osborne's 2012 gambit, which ONS stopped after my complaints).

It is marginally bad for the current budget rule and marginally good for the debt rule. Marginally is the operative word here. 3) The BoE would not have chosen to back the currency with long-dated gilts on its books, but it's not a bad thing to do with them

Today in the occasional series "we learnt something we really should have known", the Office for National Statistics learnt that people generally don't answer surveys if they are on holiday

View full thread

Today in the occasional series "we learnt something we really should have known", the Office for National Statistics learnt that people generally don't answer surveys if they are on holiday

Anyway, (for various complicated reasons due to survey quality) the upshot is measured annual UK productivity per hour since the GFC will be revised up from 1.1% to 1.3%