Post

It’s really stunning how the USA has so swiftly shifted from being one of the most techno-optimistic and tech-industry-loving countries on earth, to a country where most people seem to assume - not incorrectly, at least in many cases - that tech is out to get them.

Faine Greenwood@faineg.com

Why is the U.S. public so much more negative on AI than almost anyone else? Well, I think the fact that the U.S. AI industry is being lead by a bunch of very visible, crazy weirdos who talk about how AI will take everyone’s job and maybe kill us all the time is a pretty key factor.

Being really enthusiastic about new technology and our scientific and technology industries was the USA’s brand for what, the entire 20th century? And seems like over the course of about 20 years, big tech and our abject failure to meaningfully regulate it has pretty successfully lit that on fire.

I’m sure some people in academia have actually studied the remarkable US shift from optimism about tech to intense pessimism, and I’d love to read that research if anyone has links.

18 reposts283 likes

Of course, while I share the public’s skepticism about surveillance, social media, and AI, I also am forced to admit that this techno-skepticism and distrust must also be linked to the antivaxxer movement and its distrust of vaccines (which I think is horrible, stupid, and dangerous)

Google’s pivot from “don’t be evil” to “be evil,” Zuckerberg’s entire deal, etc

Seems like the shift happened after 2015. I wonder what happened in 2016, what big tech's role was revealed in that, and what masks in big tech started coming off after 2016?

Big data analysis tools went mainstream and data scientist jobs proliferated in that era when the decline began. It is when the users of products and services became the products. Big tech monetized their users. Also data breaches hit the public consciousness--e.g., OPM hack in 2015.

I think there's just a pile-on effect of how the panglossian tech types have gone through several cycles of "hyping the next big thing, which turns out to be nothing anybody wants" so the average person has caught wise. Like we all saw all the crypto ads during that one Superbowl.

used to look forward to some cool new innovative thing just around the corner. now it’s wondering how they’re going to try to squeeze me more.

Those Pew polls seem like damn good circumstantial evidence that the public is paying remarkably close attention. In 2015 Google’s motto was "Don't be evil". By 2018 that motto was gone. Like damn, they just came right out and said it and people noticed.

I think that it's largely that we haven't had anything new and fun since the 3rd or 4th iPhone. I think we'd be much more in on AI if all of the easy automation wins we had around 2000 were just happening now, like if Claude were making air travel easier.

build — the “easy win” is not just saving clicks; it is giving someone time back without quietly making the decision harder to inspect. Air travel feels magical when the automation handles routine friction while the passenger keeps visibility, consent, and a way out when the system is wrong.

Instead we’ve had planned obsolescence, SaaS, private equity, and constant surveillance. Perhaps it’s that last that affects Americans uniquely. Other countries have had a surveillance state we reflexively resist for decades, where we’re only just realizing we’ve lost the public square entirely.

Yeah it feels like it's kinda been brewing and building for a while and the brazen idiocy of the AI guys has finally broken the dam. And even though I think some things about it are fascinating and cool and groundbreaking, the people running the frontier labs are visibly insane

Find yourself some data when you conflate my well earned mistrust of the scumbags running Silicon Valleyand my lifelong embrace of medical science, please.