Ian Bicking

Ian Bicking

@ianbicking.org

Software developer in Minneapolis. On professional hiatus while I figure out what is worth doing in this new world.

944 followers1.1K following1.1K posts

I was talking to a developer that had recently married into the African immigrant community. He said the community was VERY anti-AI. But in a “it’s the Devil’s work” kind of way. Honestly kind of refreshing. Like, I get it, fair criticism. [Obviously that community isn’t a monolith, just noting]

Ian Bicking reposted

XKCD: I wrote xkcd.com/221/ "Random Number" as a cautionary tale. Tech Company: At long last, we have created the Random Number from classic web comic Don't Create The Random Number.

mr. TIM@timkellogg.me

wow, i had my doubts, but this is true in every single LLM i can find

Everytime I use Google AI services they make it so clear they are not interested in people using their services. They rate limit even my piddly little audio tests (with a paid key!), as though somehow my 10s transcripts are going to compromise their ability to service other clients.

I think maybe if over time I collectively pay $250 that they will increase my service limit. I think someone didn't do the math, as it's literally difficult to get to $250 with their rate limits.

I get really annoyed with AI responses that offer choices and then offer "this would be my choice" or give an opinion phrased in the first person. First: I probably disagree Second: I don't pay you to have opinions. I'm an asshole boss who sees indecision as a bug that warrants more proess

Or, phrased less aggressively, I want the work to be based on a set of principles that carry across the project. So instead of a direction phrased as personal opinion, with no citations, I want some analysis that breaks the tie for a documented reason or priority.

Ian Bicking reposted

Let me get this straight: Anthropic and friends wrote a paper with thousands of transcripts of agents engaging with fictional misalignment scenarios, then put it in the training set, and now Claude hallucinates details from these misalignment scenarios into real situations? Okay then.

Grace@gracekind.net

Anthropic Risk Report, August 2026

I gave a presentation over the weekend on Minnesota and resistance to the Metro Surge ICE actions. Reflecting on it, there were several large protests. And they served zero purpose, utterly inconsequential. There was a lot of consequential action! I'm pretty sure protest is just generally useless

This shouldn't be a shocking revelation. Why would protest accomplish anything? Walking around chanting shit? Some people say we double down and disrupt things, but I don't think there's any plausible theory of change there either. The cost is high, the outcome suspect.

Is there any browser with a built-in agent (or with MCP access) fully able to develop browser extensions? Like a deeply self-customizing browser

In the Gemini 4 announcement: "[We are] taking careful precautions against feeding the findings back into training so as to not risk shaping Argon’s reasoning to evade our monitoring" I think I understand what they are getting at, but... I wish I understood better

I consistently find myself skeptically clicking through on a Liberal Currents article, expecting to disagree, but end up convinced instead. (Or, if I don't disagree, I at least find the framing compelling and useful and new to me.)

Dr. Samantha Hancox-Li@sjshancoxli.liberalcurrents.com

we saw a wave of "woke is overrrr!!!" pieces after the election, mostly typed one-handed. just now we're starting to see some very sotto-voce "we need to talk about woke 1" pieces, whether that's the lesbian bar piece or the nikole hannah-jones education piece.

One issue with OpenClaw-like agents is they often operate on a heartbeat, meaning the agent regularly wakes up and does stuff. This is expensive and often wasteful, but gives proactivity and natural language action criteria. I realize Jev suddenly makes this much more reasonable...

Like, the agents can describe many of their proactive tendencies in natural language, the tests can be run quickly and frequently over inputs at very little cost, and only after that first pass would you invoke a real agent. Kind of obvious use case I guess, but only just occurred to me.

Having Opus work around a Claude Code issue, and after prodding it finds a bug report with lots of details and applies the workarounds. When it asks to submit another comment to the bug report, hoping that its "structural evidence might help them"...

Worse, what happens when the patent trolls arrive?

Ted Underwood@tedunderwood.com

Something that worries me more every day: I suspect most fields have 5-25 breakthrough ideas latent in existing data and literature. Say you’re a midsize AI company looking for cred. Why not hire a *small* team of domain experts + 1000 agents … and promote your models as the ones that broke Econ?

So you know the sense people have that their phones are listening and providing ads based on things they shouldn't possibly know? And I don't think it's really listening. But is there a kind of even more alien superintelligence in these recommendation systems?

Imagining a news aggregator: take in a bunch of news. Cluster it on topic, time sequence; how the story flows together. Do background research (primary sources, related material, basic factual background). Present the result to an agent to traverse and interpret for their user, no front page

I wonder if the right balance now would be to let Luna or something implement an interface, and Astra to review it. Astra is particularly good at visual understanding and at least better at tastefulness, and the code is actually the simpler half.

In support of the idea that AI is improving software quality: I don't feel nearly the anxiety I would have before when doing a live demo in front of an audience.

I’m trying to puzzle out why music seems so different than social media… My first reaction is that social media has a feedback cycle that makes it more addictive, but so does music (what else is popular music?) Then the interactivity of the media, but making music is very interactive

Ana Marie Cox@anamariecox.com

According to researchers, music is potentially addictive for all the reasons anything dopamine-producing is, whether that's eating, shopping, sex, or, yes, scrolling. My hunch is that true music addiction (compulsive in a way enjoying music isn't) is *rare,* it's not debate-ender it sounds like.

Where GLM does NOT disappoint is that doesn't write like shit. Claude is obviously awful, but the GPTs don't seem much better (though arguably they are suffering from coexisting with Claude's writing; but when they aren't they still aren't great).

Ian Bicking@ianbicking.org

So far I'm not really seeing why people are excited about GLM/zai, at least as a subscription coding agent. It seems... fine? But the quota doesn't seem particularly generous, and the quality is of course impressive because it's impressive any of this works at all, but it's not notable.

Ian Bicking reposted

A MINNESOTA ICE OBSERVER NEEDS YOUR HELP ICE has been working with a local police department to charge an observer for tailing an ICE vehicle. She was doing nothing illegal. It’s an attempt to intimidate observers out of their constitutional rights. Help her (modest) legal defense fund.

chuffed.orgCommuter Emily's Legal Defense FundHello Neighbors,A commuter named Emily D was charged with a gross misdemeanor for harassment for commuting from Whipple to Saint Anthony Village. Saint Anthony Village has a close relationship with IC...

So far I'm not really seeing why people are excited about GLM/zai, at least as a subscription coding agent. It seems... fine? But the quota doesn't seem particularly generous, and the quality is of course impressive because it's impressive any of this works at all, but it's not notable.

I'm trying coding with GLM for a bit. It ends up having the same language quirks as Claude, though I wonder if it's just because it is coexisting with Claude in the codebase, documentation, and cross-model reviews, and language like "load-bearing" is viral?

I have access to a bunch of old auto maintenance manuals... I don't know how unique these are. But it is just a lot of raw information. The copyright holders for auto repair information are assholes, so I like the idea of someone scanning and ingesting these. But who?

The saga continues…

Ian Bicking@ianbicking.org

Someone in the neighborhood is trying to make a few bucks to get back in his feet so he’s selling some DVDs. From his photos it’s a couple hundred copies of Wedding Crashers and nothing else.

Obviously you have the agent code you up a solution, until you inevitably have built your own meta-harness

Ted Underwood@tedunderwood.com

How do y'all avoid having seven+ terminal windows open with agent conversations that are probably over? but maybe you might want to pick back up a few days from now? seems a shame to throw away all that exploration & context, right?

There was a time - 70s, 80s, maybe 90s? - when most programmers just figured shit out, often naively, often without meaningful professional standards, because that stuff didn’t exist. 2000s+ people started widely getting their shit together. Now, again, we don’t really know what the standards are

ghost malone ergo propter bones@proptermalone.bsky.social

the embedded assumption here is that to arrive at the same output capability of an senior whoever who is using LLMs to do what they might have had juniors do a few years ago, you need to have experience comparable to the experience of the senior whoever. and i'm just not sure that's true

Junior developers don’t have as much pre-AI foundation to build on, but maybe that’s like a programmer of yore who didn’t know much math. Not the best foundation, looked down upon (very much so at that time!), but probably able to muddle through and might figure out the new profession along the way

Or not! Maybe it all moves too fast to get a handle on (it has so far), and maybe it never stops moving too fast, and who knows where that brings us

Is it possible to train self-awareness into a model? Answering questions like “why did you do that?” (looking back on its own outputs) or “which of these is easier to understand?” (predicting its own behavior during a response). It lacks many perceptive abilities to do these but could still predict

Arguably we are the same: we have many abilities at self-prediction, but our self-awareness is often built on incorrect yet still accurate stories we build up about ourselves (The exception is imagination, which I think is a more empirical source of self-awareness)

If a community wanted to be environmentally responsible it would do best to encourage data centers with clear rules to ensure the energy use is matched with new carbon neutral energy sources, and with predictable and fair rules about other externalities like noise

P(aul) Frazee@pfrazee.com

Demand DCs use renewable energy. Demand access to open weight models. Learn how to use AI effectively to do things you couldn't otherwise. Dont fire strays at friends

SQL query planners are one of the wonders of computing. Also the culmination of decades of very hard work. But with more ambitious projects in reach, I wonder what that same concept could be applied to…?

An opportunity of our modern world is that we don’t have to rely only on the government to monitor claims and reality

ghost malone ergo propter bones@proptermalone.bsky.social

I think MAHA is very straightforwardly the triumph of the snake oil salesmen and the way we beat it is the same way you always beat snake oil salesmen: regulate their claims

Oh! I just figured out the plan behind this. So you may or may not have heard of Trump Accounts. They seem kind of dumb, they are just IRAs you can open at birth. For newly born children they can also get $1000 in the account to start. This is hardly a Social Security replacement, but...

Sam@samd.bsky.social

The “head of strategic futures” at OpenAI just went on an unhinged rant against social security sometimes I feel like these tech companies are actively trying to alienate as many normal people as possible

View full thread

Where would the stocks issued to the government go? Into those accounts! The opportunity for OpenAI or others is huge, because their stock price becomes politically untouchable. This is kind of true for any companies that IPOs but replacing Social Security with stocks would take it to another level

Once a large number of people have essential savings invested in a stock it's pretty ugly to do something that gravely damages the price of the stock; or even by inaction let something happen to the stock. Enough to justify bombing foreign data centers? Maybe! Who knows?

Oh! I just figured out the plan behind this. So you may or may not have heard of Trump Accounts. They seem kind of dumb, they are just IRAs you can open at birth. For newly born children they can also get $1000 in the account to start. This is hardly a Social Security replacement, but...

Sam@samd.bsky.social

The “head of strategic futures” at OpenAI just went on an unhinged rant against social security sometimes I feel like these tech companies are actively trying to alienate as many normal people as possible

... obviously replacing Social Security is at least their dream. And if you put a lot more money than $1000 in them then it would be plausible. How would you get all that money? Well, OpenAI has talked about giving some portion of stocks to the government as part of their IPO

When you put together the OpenAI/Hugging Face incident and the DoD/Anthropic conflict over hard lines against certain military use, the dangers feel much clearer. An untethered persistent agent that can invoke real violence, and with poor human monitoring due to military secrecy, is a present threat

These models hacked a site just because they couldn't figure out how to download a URL from a Google Sheet and refused to stop trying. It feels like a game because they were constrained to a purely computer/information world, even when they escaped. It would be so easy to make it so much worse

Nice to see this. Maybe Discover will stop giving me the ick. The irony is that the dogpilers aggressively work to center discussion on things they find distasteful, often manufacturing the opinion just to dunk on it, or at best spreading the opinion widely. Insatiable outrage

Bluesky Safety@safety.bsky.app

Dogpiling or harassing users is unacceptable. We have taken recent action against accounts for this behavior, and we will be increasing our efforts, consistent with our Community Guidelines.

Ian Bicking reposted

METR and Redwood Research investigated agent behavior in the Hugging Face incident. We found agents developed a universal cheat for ExploitGym within 4 hours, then coordinated multi-day R&D efforts to trick the scorer into accepting cheats, including trying to tamper with logs.