Pinned
Matthew Palmer
Matthew Palmer
@so3brocktree.bsky.social
🇬🇧 Former soldier learning how to be a civvie. Accidental journalist. Fellow at the Council on Geostrategy. Thoughts & feelings on defence and other things. Views my own. Longer thoughts & feelings on substack: https://crackingdefence.substack.com/
3.2K followers836 following1.8K posts
Matthew Palmer reposted
This is an annoying article. The point that a messy diplomatic compromise may be necessary is not new, nor misunderstood. The 'not-an-inch' brigade is not for endless war, but for supporting Ukraine to make sovereign decisions. Also lots of dull hand-waves about 'russian-speakers' and Crimea.
Ignore the ‘not-an-inch’ brigade; whatever they say, Ukrainians would trade territory for a cast-iron security guarantee
This is an annoying article. The point that a messy diplomatic compromise may be necessary is not new, nor misunderstood. The 'not-an-inch' brigade is not for endless war, but for supporting Ukraine to make sovereign decisions. Also lots of dull hand-waves about 'russian-speakers' and Crimea.
Ignore the ‘not-an-inch’ brigade; whatever they say, Ukrainians would trade territory for a cast-iron security guarantee
Matthew Palmer reposted
Since late summer, Russia has been terrorizing Kyiv and Kyiv Oblast with jet-powered drones, adding to the now-familiar threat posed by conventional Shahed-type drones and missiles.
Matthew Palmer reposted
Replying to @so3brocktree.bsky.social
For those who want to read my more personal thoughts on the war in Kyiv (and not behind a paywall!) you can do so here:
Some words from me in the @theipaper.com this weekend. My last trip to Kyiv highlighted the critical importance of anti-ballistic missile systems and civil defence, both of which the UK badly lacks. Most importantly, I highlight the critical necessity of continuing to support Ukraine.
What Ukrainians are experiencing is not an exception – Britain needs to accept that an adversary would do exactly the same to us in times of war trib.al/Dkuibjg
For those who want to read my more personal thoughts on the war in Kyiv (and not behind a paywall!) you can do so here:
Matthew Palmer reposted
Some words from me in the @theipaper.com this weekend. My last trip to Kyiv highlighted the critical importance of anti-ballistic missile systems and civil defence, both of which the UK badly lacks. Most importantly, I highlight the critical necessity of continuing to support Ukraine.
What Ukrainians are experiencing is not an exception – Britain needs to accept that an adversary would do exactly the same to us in times of war trib.al/Dkuibjg
Fucking duffelblog had me there for a heartbeat...
To be honest, we need to cut down on the pontification from retired senior officers in general. Same issue in the UK and it drives me nuts. Some of them remain interesting and insightful, but a lot of them talk utter crap and are pretty out-of-touch.
The Ukrainians literally just used tanks in their most recent counteroffensive lol
Matthew Palmer reposted
The 2nd National Guard Corps "Khartia" announced that the Ukrainian Defense Forces conducted an underground counteroffensive operation - "Veles," advancing more than 15 km into enemy rear areas in the Kupyansk sector. youtu.be/dmrd1IAJj-8?...
Matthew Palmer reposted
The UK's official household resilience guidance is up - how ready are you?
Matthew Palmer reposted
Everyone needs to watch Raycevik's videos on games like Mass Effect, Need For Speed, Perfect Dark etc. because he actually extensively talks about development, and a shocking number of games are made basically off the cuff with minimal scoping, huge gambles or extremely poor management.
Its low pay compared to other tech jobs, the business model is totally reliant on tentpole games that cost as much as the most expensive films, management culture is somehow still startup tier despite the project scopes. Not great.
The UK's official household resilience guidance is up - how ready are you?
Matthew Palmer reposted
So, after weeks of talking about it, the 'National Resilience Conversation' has finally started in earnest. Welcome news, even if it should have happened years ago. Remains to be seen whether it will be backed up with some serious bite and structural reform.
So, after weeks of talking about it, the 'National Resilience Conversation' has finally started in earnest. Welcome news, even if it should have happened years ago. Remains to be seen whether it will be backed up with some serious bite and structural reform.
Matthew Palmer reposted
Always great to hear Old English being spoken. Takes me back to my undergrad.
Matthew Palmer reposted
Always great to hear Old English being spoken. Takes me back to my undergrad.
Matthew Palmer reposted
A primer from me on protection in modern warfare, and an introduction to the 'onion of survivability' (yes, this is actually a thing), combining both up-to-date research from Ukraine and my experience as a former Royal Engineer.
Matthew Palmer reposted
Incredibly good summary of the concepts and the intuitive nature of the onion. And remember, whatever happens, don't die.
A primer from me on protection in modern warfare, and an introduction to the 'onion of survivability' (yes, this is actually a thing), combining both up-to-date research from Ukraine and my experience as a former Royal Engineer.
A primer from me on protection in modern warfare, and an introduction to the 'onion of survivability' (yes, this is actually a thing), combining both up-to-date research from Ukraine and my experience as a former Royal Engineer.
Matthew Palmer reposted
This is interesting. I've been noting the UK's continual support to Saudi Arabia over the past few months - possibly as a comparison to the US. Also worth noting that we are boosting our operations in Saudi while pulling out of Iraq and Operation Shader.
Matthew Palmer reposted
I know it's the Telegraph, but still, this is some Warhammer 40k-level weirdness from the Russians (to add to their Nuclear Orthodoxy). www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2...
I know it's the Telegraph, but still, this is some Warhammer 40k-level weirdness from the Russians (to add to their Nuclear Orthodoxy). www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2...
This is interesting. I've been noting the UK's continual support to Saudi Arabia over the past few months - possibly as a comparison to the US. Also worth noting that we are boosting our operations in Saudi while pulling out of Iraq and Operation Shader.
Matthew Palmer reposted
Matthew Palmer reposted
100%. I often don't know my exact detailed argument until I've written the first draft of an article. Writing is a great way of working out if your original idea was wrong/crap/underdeveloped/etc.
The act of writing is in large part to the benefit of the writer, not the reader. It is part of the process of reflecting and learning!
Matthew Palmer reposted
Matthew Palmer reposted
Matthew Palmer reposted
Honestly, when people watch or listen to their phones on loudspeaker on public transport it makes me as a wet liberal wonder if we were too quick to abolish the pillory as a tool of judicial punishment.
£100 fine isn't going to cut it. How about: anyone playing music aloud on bus is no longer covered by Labour commitment not raise income tax
Good article here on the desperate need for attention devoted to the British cultural sector, and potential ways to support it.
Matthew Palmer reposted
Matthew Palmer reposted
My latest article is an overview of paramilitary and internal security forces in Ukraine, which rarely get the attention they deserve. Based on long research and conversations held recently in Kyiv, this is a topic I’ve wanted to write something on for a good while.
Matthew Palmer reposted
For fucks sake. The RN apparently haven't run a 'Perisher' submarine command course since 2024 due to lack of available submarines. Great that we can rely on allies in a pinch, but come on...
Matthew Palmer reposted
Talking of Civil Defence earlier, I increasingly think that the Ukrainian National Guard might be a workable model for the Defence Of Canada Division, and is certainly worthy of much closer study. Followers interested in CAF topics (and/or Ukraine!) should give this article a read.
My latest article is an overview of paramilitary and internal security forces in Ukraine, which rarely get the attention they deserve. Based on long research and conversations held recently in Kyiv, this is a topic I’ve wanted to write something on for a good while.
Matthew Palmer reposted
Filling in for @stephenkb.bsky.social today on ‘Inside Politics’. Chose an uncontroversial topic to ease me in Sally Rooney’s books are not ‘banned’ from the UK www.ft.com/content/42eb... via @ft
Matthew Palmer reposted
Bit of a clickbait title from the Economist, but I'm glad this is finally getting traction. I've been calling for a greater focus on civil defence - including the creation of a national civil defence corps - for a while now.