Rami Jarrah

Rami Jarrah

@ramijarrah.com

Remnants of a war Journalist | AKA Alexander Page | @CJFE Intl Press Freedom Award

9.7K followers60 following827 posts

Rami Jarrah reposted

Mustafa Bakour, the Damascus-appointed Governor of Suwayda, seeks to justify holding Druze victims of kidnapping in Adra Prison as “precautionary detention” to avoid further violence. bsky.app/profile/rami...

Rami Jarrah@ramijarrah.com

Mustafa Bakour, the so-called “governor of Suwayda” the appointee Sharaa’s bootlickers are praising, makes a stark admission that the state took Druze civilians kidnapped by Bedouin tribes, instead of freeing them, locked them up to use as leverage for Bedouins kidnapped by Druze militias. 1/8

Rami Jarrah reposted

This is not what Lavrov said in the TGRT Haber interview that Al Arabiya is citing. When asked about Russia’s position on legal action against Assad, who is residing in Moscow, Lavrov said: "This issue has not been on the agenda for a long time. Our partners know very well how everything is" 1/4

This is not what Lavrov said in the TGRT Haber interview that Al Arabiya is citing. When asked about Russia’s position on legal action against Assad, who is residing in Moscow, Lavrov said: "This issue has not been on the agenda for a long time. Our partners know very well how everything is" 1/4

View full thread

The practical benefits of the lifted UN sanctions: • Personal sanctions lifted on Sharaa and Khattab, travel bans removed, able to handle money and benefit economically, including UN funds • Delisted HTS figures can legally join the government, hold ministries, and engage diplomatically 3/4

Not demanding Assad’s extradition isn’t the issue. Striking a deal behind closed doors is. If the state respected its people, it would have been transparent. Syria is not a private farm and decisions of this scale cannot be dictated in secret by Sharaa. Otherwise, we’re back to square one. 4/4

This is not what Lavrov said in the TGRT Haber interview that Al Arabiya is citing. When asked about Russia’s position on legal action against Assad, who is residing in Moscow, Lavrov said: "This issue has not been on the agenda for a long time. Our partners know very well how everything is" 1/4

Even so, the meaning stands: Sharaa has been Lying to Syrians. By secretly dropping the demand for Assad’s extradition they signal to Russia they don’t intend to pursue justice for millions of Syrians, instead focused on removing Sharaa from the UN terrorist list by ensuring no Russian veto. 2/4

Muhammad Baraa Shakri has been appointed Acting Ambassador at the Syrian Embassy in Berlin. It should, of course, come as no surprise that his father is the current Minister of Endowment. 1/2

I say it’s hardly surprising because the distribution of posts among relatives and the spread of rampant nepotism have become routine since Sharaa took power, justified by what he likes to call: “homogeneity" "التجانس” a gentleman's way of saying he wants no opposition and absolute control. 2/2

Call it much-needed diplomacy or pragmatism or whatever, but while Sharaa praises the “bravery” of the Russian army in Moscow, Syrians will remember very well the horrors Putin's killing machine wreaked on our people: bombs, mass graves, and homes reduced to dust. 1/3

Yet now, it’s as if the burden falls on the witness, for having seen the faces of mothers & fathers stunned in silence, too shattered to even react, as the lifeless bodies of their most precious were pulled from beneath the rubble, realizing that their lives would never be the same again. 2/3

And so in the name of the children of Syria, anyone claiming to represent them who flatters the military that made sure they'd never see another day, is spitting in the face of every family that has been destroyed. 3/3

Mustafa Bakour, the so-called “governor of Suwayda” the appointee Sharaa’s bootlickers are praising, makes a stark admission that the state took Druze civilians kidnapped by Bedouin tribes, instead of freeing them, locked them up to use as leverage for Bedouins kidnapped by Druze militias. 1/8

View full thread

Let's also not forget when the governor appeared in a video back in July sat in a room with kidnapped women & children from Suwayda, to claim they were “safe” people were already outraged by the spectacle. It’s even more disturbing to realize that soon after they were thrown into prison. 7/8

A real state frees its citizens and prosecutes criminals. It wouldn’t waste a second entertaining the perverse thought of trading away its own citizens. Holding them for exchange doesn’t show authority. It shows that the state sees the people of Suwayda as nothing but expendable collateral. 8/8

Mustafa Bakour, the so-called “governor of Suwayda” the appointee Sharaa’s bootlickers are praising, makes a stark admission that the state took Druze civilians kidnapped by Bedouin tribes, instead of freeing them, locked them up to use as leverage for Bedouins kidnapped by Druze militias. 1/8

View full thread

Anyone arguing that releasing these civilians weakens the state’s ability to recover the Bedouins is admitting the deliberate detention of innocent people as leverage. If Hijri does not represent Suwayda, then these civilians have nothing to do with him and should never be tied to his actions. 5/8

Conditioning their freedom on what another group does makes the state a a partner in crime and exposes Sharaa's willingness to keep innocent Druze civilians locked up to secure Bedouins, favoring one community over another, which ustifyies the people of Suwayda rejecting Sharaa's government. 6/8

Mustafa Bakour, the so-called “governor of Suwayda” the appointee Sharaa’s bootlickers are praising, makes a stark admission that the state took Druze civilians kidnapped by Bedouin tribes, instead of freeing them, locked them up to use as leverage for Bedouins kidnapped by Druze militias. 1/8

View full thread

Context: During the July Suwayda crisis, Bedouin tribes kidnapped civilians, the state then gained custody, but instead of letting them go, sent them to prison to hold as leverage. These were not criminals, but victims who were turned into detainees by the very state claiming to protect them. 3/8

This isn’t law enforcement, it’s hostage-taking under the guise of an official authority. The state simply recycled the kidnapping and used innocent people as bargaining chips, which can only be described as collective punishment. It’s immoral, illegal, and the behavior of a militia. 4/8

Mustafa Bakour, the so-called “governor of Suwayda” the appointee Sharaa’s bootlickers are praising, makes a stark admission that the state took Druze civilians kidnapped by Bedouin tribes, instead of freeing them, locked them up to use as leverage for Bedouins kidnapped by Druze militias. 1/8

When asked why the hostages aren't released “it's complicated” the governor says, justifying it under “precautionary detention” When the presenter reacts with shock that the state is exchanging its own citizens, the governor snaps, telling him not to call it that, then calls it “the exchange.” 2/8

Rami Jarrah reposted

Replying to @ramijarrah.com

It is, of course, the Syrian state that bears full responsibility, because it is the state that must grant access to independent media and journalists, and not just to those who see themselves as guardians of the state. 8/9

Rami Jarrah reposted

🧵" I'm not ISIS" The man in this video is a former ISIS member trying to deceive his way out of prison (Al-Hol Camp Northern Syria). Both videos in this thread make that abundantly clear: 1/9

🧵" I'm not ISIS" The man in this video is a former ISIS member trying to deceive his way out of prison (Al-Hol Camp Northern Syria). Both videos in this thread make that abundantly clear: 1/9

View full thread

It is, of course, the Syrian state that bears full responsibility, because it is the state that must grant access to independent media and journalists, and not just to those who see themselves as guardians of the state. 8/9

This is the only mechanism through which such attempts can be challenged and exposed. Otherwise, we are left with what looks less like journalism and more like efforts to invent pretexts for further conflict. 9/9

🧵" I'm not ISIS" The man in this video is a former ISIS member trying to deceive his way out of prison (Al-Hol Camp Northern Syria). Both videos in this thread make that abundantly clear: 1/9

View full thread

I'm not defending the SDF, just a point that one's grievances with them shouldn't mean engaging in reckless journalism, all it does is provoke those on the other side to respond. We end up in competition of deception, which is just another one of the depravities the current conflict generates. 6/9

The current conflict in northern Syria is creating layer upon layer of hatred and division, polarization the entire debate around how to move forward, a stark contrast to the unity Al-Sharaa claims the the deployment of his forces was meant to achieve. 7/9

🧵" I'm not ISIS" The man in this video is a former ISIS member trying to deceive his way out of prison (Al-Hol Camp Northern Syria). Both videos in this thread make that abundantly clear: 1/9

View full thread

Of course, many sharing the videos of prisoners who claim their innocence are genuinely concerned and rightfully so. They should speak out and defend any potential victims of false imprisonment, and certainly if they've been falsely accused of terrorism. No one should wish that on their enemy. 4/9

But there is also no shortage of those who don’t care about such victims at all and are simply shilling for the state and trying to score points against their adversaries, exploiting anything they can to land a political blow. 5/9

🧵" I'm not ISIS" The man in this video is a former ISIS member trying to deceive his way out of prison (Al-Hol Camp Northern Syria). Both videos in this thread make that abundantly clear: 1/9

But there's a fiasco playing out on pan-Arab media, along with Syrian state propagandists posing as journalists, that have presented this danger. A clear attempt to portray widespread false imprisonment on terrorism charges in the camp before the facts have even been verified. 2/9

This is dangerous not only because it risks terrorists escaping, but also the less obvious problem behind that risk, where those who should be reporting objectively, are weaponizing these prisoners to serve their side of a media war, with little regard for the damage it causes in the process. 3/9

Rami Jarrah reposted

The images of children emerging from prison are a stain on the SDF and on anyone attempting to downplay them, they constitute a profound moral & institutional failure. Imprisoning adults unlawfully is a crime of the highest magnitude, mind you a child who cannot legally bear criminal responsibility.

The images of children emerging from prison are a stain on the SDF and on anyone attempting to downplay them, they constitute a profound moral & institutional failure. Imprisoning adults unlawfully is a crime of the highest magnitude, mind you a child who cannot legally bear criminal responsibility.

Even if a child were to commit murder, prison is not where they belong. The long-lasting psychological and developmental damage that may have been inflicted on these children amounts to the destruction of human life.

"Even if it means turning Qamishlo or Hasakah into Gaza" These are the sort of sick people we need as far away from Syria as possible, those who bear no real connection to Syria beyond a shared religious identity and are comfortable advocating the destruction of our towns and communities.

🧵What appears to be 21 civilians, some with their hands tied behind their backs, suggesting they've been executed, have appeared in two separate videos that seem to have been filmed last night and today. Both videos are clearly of the same incident, as the victims’ clothing matches. 1/4

View full thread

Even if the claim of an offensive by state aligned forces were true, nothing justifies such brutality. If the victims were indeed Arab civilians collectively punished based on their identity for actions they had nothing to do with, this marks a deeply grim development. 3/4

The longer this war drags on the more likely Syrians will never heal. It's absurd anyone believes it can end well. Even if the state ends up governing all Syrian territory, depicting "unity", what unity? the scars, hatred and deep mistrust this conflict will generate leaves no room for cohesion 4/4

🧵What appears to be 21 civilians, some with their hands tied behind their backs, suggesting they've been executed, have appeared in two separate videos that seem to have been filmed last night and today. Both videos are clearly of the same incident, as the victims’ clothing matches. 1/4

Reports indicate the killings took place in a village outside Kobani. In last night's video a man speaking in Kurmanji claims responsibility for the massacre, saying it was carried out in retaliation for an attack on Kobani, that Kurdish fighters won't let an attack on the town go unanswered. 2/4

🧵The situation in Al-Hol camp is inhumane. Children growing up in conditions that cause lasting developmental harm. I know it's a complex issue, but by the time the adults are deemed rehabilitated the children will have spent their early years in the camp and suffered irreversible damage. 1/5

View full thread

I'm not arguing for the premature release of those in Al-Hol camp. I'm saying we need expertise, investment and external oversight. Otherwise they're effectively being sentenced to death, which is unacceptable. Many haven't committed crimes and are just trapped by ideology, especially children. 4/5

Those in Al-Hol camp who were directly involved with ISIS or engaged in acts of terrorism must, of course, face consequences to protect the general public. But even then, the process must be bound by law and basic human rights. 5/5 END

🧵The situation in Al-Hol camp is inhumane. Children growing up in conditions that cause lasting developmental harm. I know it's a complex issue, but by the time the adults are deemed rehabilitated the children will have spent their early years in the camp and suffered irreversible damage. 1/5

In various conflicting ways, those in Al-Hol camp are being exploited by all sides, and it just seems like the conversation is about nuclear waste, something everyone wants someone else to bury, or like props to be put in front of a camera to serve whatever narrative suits the moment. 2/5

Politics aside, but the thousands being held in Al-Hol camp are human beings, and leaving them and their families in these unmistakably horrible conditions is a slow, deliberate destruction of human lives that nobody should be condoning. 3/5

🧵The reality is that a Sunni Arab affiliated with the SDF can be apprehended by the Syrian army, claim to have been coerced into joining, and walk away without charge. A Kurd on the other hand is more likely to undergo a traumatic experience, potentially a moment that could be their last. 1/5

View full thread

In a country uniquely as diverse as Syria, any force that claims national legitimacy cannot carry itself like a tribal militia that appears compassionate to one community over another. 4/5

A people's army must be founded on the diversity of its people, able to collectively see all Syrians as their own. Otherwise it cannot function as a national army, and Syrians will in turn view such an army based on their own religious/ethnic makeup, to some a liberator, to others an occupier. 5/5

🧵The reality is that a Sunni Arab affiliated with the SDF can be apprehended by the Syrian army, claim to have been coerced into joining, and walk away without charge. A Kurd on the other hand is more likely to undergo a traumatic experience, potentially a moment that could be their last. 1/5

I'm not saying the same doesn't hold true when the roles are reversed, I'm saying that all the fighting factions in Syria, including the Syrian army, are plagued in tribalism, which reinforces a broader point I'm making: HTS has failed to build a national army which was of course inevitable. 2/5

Instead of undoing the exclusionary identity-based foundations of the Syrian 'Arab' Army, HTS under the leadership of Ahmad Al-Sharaa, has reinforced them by adding a 'Sunni' layer on top, further narrowing its potential to represent. 3/5

You can reject the conflation of the SDF with the Kurds and still recognize that the hybrid, identity-based conflict now unfolding risks inflicting much deeper, long-term scars on Arab–Kurdish cohesion in Syria. The hatred this conflict is spewing, both on and off the battlefield, is alarming.

The longer this goes on the less likely we'll heal from it. Dividing a country begins by dividing its people, and so rooting for any side to win in the name of a unified Syria is irony. We should focus on ending the fighting, because the consequences will far outweigh any gains from military action.