"We never imagined [the Kalven Report] would be adopted by other institutions." Lots of insights (and opinions) here on free speech and academic freedom, especially with respect to college faculty, at this new Forum for Free Inquiry and Expression event at UChicago. news.uchicago.edu/story/uchica...
Kiernan Mathews
Kiernan Mathews
@faculty.bsky.social
I study faculty, direct a university consortium, and reveal the known universe of #highered scholarship to people who never thought to ask. Trying to change a 19th century academy for a 21st century professoriate. Failing daily.
422 followers562 following310 posts
Evergreen insight: “We realized that the obstacle to these fixes is not always resources. It’s faculty culture and the absence of structured opportunities to surface and work through disagreement… and that requires a sustained investment in faculty development that most programs have yet to make.”
What is the PhD for? What are we actually preparing these students to do? Asking faculty to articulate the purpose of each program requirement opens up debates about program purpose that we have too long avoided. Read 5 insights from our Doctoral Futures town halls: https://bit.ly/4w41FXJ
💃"Let's. Do. The Time. Warp. Again!!!"💃🍞👄 @nytimes.com 2001 --> @chronicle.com 2026
From the brilliant @alvintilleryjr.bsky.social, the analogy we’ve been looking for Alito’s argument re: Louisiana v. Callais. “like arguing that a homeowner must tear down their fence because the fence discriminates against a burglar’s right of access.“ open.substack.com/pub/alvintil...
Is a university board’s duty to protect the institution or its mission? Per AGB, it’s the mission. The “duty of obedience” requires boards ensure their institution operates to further its stated purposes—and to amend the mission itself when necessary. Mission is the North Star. 1/2
I'm looking for Hanover Research's 2023 report, "Higher Education Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Survey." Anybody have it? No longer on their website. "Insights Blog" post disappeared. LinkedIn posts about it deleted. The Internet Archive Wayback Machine: web.archive.org/web/20240812...
An Ivy+ Mellon Leadership Fellows gets Duke’s award for those who reject the false choice between being a great scholar and being a great teacher. #facultyadvancementnetwork
The world is on fire & this has also been an awful year personally, BUT last night I was awarded a Bass Professorship at Duke, an endowed chair in recognition of research, undergrad teaching, & leadership. I had no idea I’d been nominated & am very, very moved by this honor. Esp the teaching part.
For the FAN Fellows engaging this year’s Institute on Faculty Voice & Collaborative Leadership, file this under “faculty rights and responsibilities“. #academicfreedom
Now posted ahead of print: "Conceptualizing Academic Freedom," forthcoming, Annual Review of Political Science. (Uncorrected proofs, so a few minor edits different from the version that will be published in June.) doi.org/10.1146/annu...
Kiernan Mathews reposted
This analysis of how ideas spread in the early scientific revolution, from person to person and place to place, lines up so nicely with @alliemorgan.bsky.social's 2018 paper on the diffusion of scientific ideas via modern faculty hiring networks epjdatascience.springeropen.com/articles/10....
Kiernan Mathews reposted
Kiernan Mathews reposted
Building a playlist for music to meet the moment, I’ve only just discovered this sweet 2m40s from early in The Mountain Goats’ discography: themountaingoats.bandcamp.com/track/color-... “They came in by the dozens, walking or crawling / Some were bright-eyed, some were dead on their feet…”
This is a high-quality take on trustees in @insidehighered.com, incl. Toor's comparison of boards + profs: "As with faculty development, those who are eager to get better at their jobs attend learning sessions and those who most need training rarely show up." www.insidehighered.com/opinion/view...
"The world disappoints, but the universe never does." - Priyamvada Natarajan, Professor of Astronomy at @yale.edu
“Yet [Mordecai] firmly said that he would sooner shut down his university than allow anyone to dictate what its STUDENTS COULD OR COULD NOT LEARN.” Is there a more crisp defense of academic freedom? This framing by @jelaniya.bsky.social seems unassailable. www.newyorker.com/magazine/202...
Kiernan Mathews reposted
Replying to @juliafstrand.bsky.social
It has been loads of fun and is super popular (full auditoriums). It also happens to be very little work to organize. If you'd like to offer Guess Lectures at your institution, I wrote up a set of instructions to make it easier for you. Reach out with questions! docs.google.com/document/d/1...
Recently recommended because the transcripts of confidential search committee meetings "will occupy real estate in your brain forever": When Two Bodies Are (Not) a Problem: Gender & Relationship Status Discrimination in Academic Hiring, by @larivera.bsky.social advance.charlotte.edu/wp-content/u...
“Brown Professor Avoids Defunding by Adding ‘For Bombs’ to Research Abstract” by Ray Theon “At press time, Norman was encouraging a colleague in the Africana Studies Department to add ‘for white people too’ to the title of her upcoming talk.” thenoser.com/article/Brow...
A statement from @bigtenacademic.bsky.social: That "mutual defense compact"? It's still not going to happen. btaa.org/big-ten-acad...
This by @guttergeek.bsky.social is required reading for anyone who thought a "NATO-like" defense compact at @bigtenacademic.bsky.social was viable. (TL;DR: It's not.) campus-novel.ghost.io/the-big10-mu...
Perhaps there are proportionally fewer white men on Harvard's faculty because the 👏old 👏ways👏were👏 discriminatory--white men were OVERrepresented. Now (thanks to DEI?) processes are 👏less 👏discriminatory. (❤️ @emmajanepettit.bsky.social for White-Lewis insight, too.) www.chronicle.com/article/facu...
Kiernan Mathews reposted
A truly wonderful experience for me, thanks to @dartmouthartsci.bsky.social & the inimitable @faculty.bsky.social & his team (I miss Dustin already!)
I'm inspired by these faculty who, many times over the course of a difficult year, found time away from the constant pressures of their work/lives to rethink + reinvent the "Ivy Plus" norms (+ other powers/privileges) they've inherited. #selfpromotion facultyadvancement.duke.edu/news/strengt...
I'm inspired by these faculty who, many times over the course of a difficult year, found time away from the constant pressures of their work/lives to rethink + reinvent the "Ivy Plus" norms (+ other powers/privileges) they've inherited. #selfpromotion facultyadvancement.duke.edu/news/strengt...
This by @guttergeek.bsky.social is required reading for anyone who thought a "NATO-like" defense compact at @bigtenacademic.bsky.social was viable. (TL;DR: It's not.) campus-novel.ghost.io/the-big10-mu...
Gratuitous self-citation to my skeets about this 17d ago: bsky.app/profile/facu... Fortunately for us, @guttergeek.bsky.social has unpacked the resolution's problems in detail.
There may be a role for @bigtenacademic.bsky.social to play, but this is likely not it. It’s a mature (67yo), high-functioning consortium w/$12M+ in rev & a HQ in Champaign, but it’s largely does prof dev, communities of practice & shared services, w/occasional forays into research (e.g. CTE). /1
Also by @garceslm.bsky.social + @jackiepedota.bsky.social: Universities must collectively invest in faculty capacity to navigate legal pressures + disrupt suppression. Include a history lesson on academic freedom because minoritized scholars are less protected. www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10....
In "We're on Our Own Out Here," @jackiepedota.bsky.social + @garceslm.bsky.social show how silence from university leaders—not bills per se—pushed faculty to self-censor race teaching + research. But not if president, provost, dean, chair, sr. faculty speak out. www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10....
Another banger by @aaronclauset.bsky.social + @jenniebrand.bsky.social: When early-career researchers work in diverse teams, they're more likely to build their own diverse teams in the future — helping to break the usual pattern where people mostly work with others who are similar to themselves.
📢Out now! Weihua Li, @jenniebrand.bsky.social, @aaronclauset.bsky.social, and colleagues show that researchers’ early training in diverse environments is strongly correlated with nurturing diverse groups in the established period. www.nature.com/articles/s43... #cssky #NetSci
Kiernan Mathews reposted
🧪 Reports from inside NSF - staff were informed another huge set of grants were terminated today, that NSF will have at least a 50% total RIF, & no Acting Director has been appointed. So, who is leading NSF? #SciSky @science.org @scinews.bsky.social @aaas.org @aeraedresearch.bsky.social
See this explainer from @bostonu.bsky.social: www.bu.edu/teaching-wri....
Survey of first-generation scholars finds many struggle with ‘unwritten rules’ of academic life #highered #EduSky
I was an altar boy in a parish convulsed by the "agony of the sex-abuse crisis". The Church's many failures of contrition pushed me out; Francis called me back. But to Douthat, compassionate, pastoral leadership is weak. It wasn't JP2 or Benedict, but Francis who ended "infallibility's mystique".
Jim Nantz inadvertently predicting the @uhoustonclass.bsky.social loss here. We sure will 'Remember the Alamodome,' Jim. We sure will.
“For the rest of our lives — the University of Houston — we’ll be looking back on one weekend in San Antonio, and we’re gonna say, after we get done tomorrow night, ‘Remember the Alamodome.’” -Jim Nantz
“Race is, in many ways, a superseding factor... Being a person of color, being Black, or being someone who comes from an underrepresented ethnic group like Latinos leads to poorer outcomes.” -- @jamiemerisotis.bsky.social, CEO, @luminafoundation.bsky.social www.newyorker.com/magazine/202...
“Being a person of color, being Black, or being someone who comes from an underrepresented ethnic group like Latinos leads to poorer outcomes. To walk away from the construct of race or ethnicity means our collective talent as a nation will suffer.” -- @jamiemerisotis.bsky.social, CEO, Lumina
As my mentor at Harvard told me 20 years ago: if you compromise your integrity, you have nothing.
As someone directly affected by this, let me be clear: I'd rather lose my job because Harvard chose to fight than keep my job and see a generation of white supremacists parade its corpse around like a war trophy.
Solid coverage by @mzahneis.bsky.social on this NATO-inspired agreement gaining steam among faculty senates. I’m not sure though that state schools can (or can politically) spend their residents’ tax + tuition dollars on defending faculty at out-of-state schools... www.chronicle.com/article/thes...
Here’s how it would likely look, *if* enough CAOs agreed (c.f. bylaws) to this idea from Rutgers’ faculty: the BTAA would negotiate a deal w/a law firm to be the house counsel for academic legal defense. So, not a “fund” at the consortium, but a “cut rate” on a shared service members can use. /2
Kiernan Mathews reposted
In economics, mentoring Ph.D. students and new doctorates from historically underrepresented minority groups appears to boost their probability of ultimately holding a tenure-track or tenured position. www.nber.org/papers/w33689
This is a well-sourced (e.g. @cantb.bsky.social) @bostonglobe.com piece on the demographic cliff in Massachusetts by @jonmarcusboston.bsky.social, one of the best #highered journalists I've met: www.bostonglobe.com/2025/04/09/magazine/massachusetts-colleges-face-enrollment-drop-higher-ed-crisis
... and I do not understand why the NYT-owned @bostonglobe.com *still* has no "gift article" option for subscribers.
This phenomenon is attributed to the ‘86 ADEA by Congress ending mandatory retirement for faculty. In “The Faculty Factor,” Conley, Finkelstein & Schuster (2016), respected #highered scholars, make a compelling, ADEA-compliant case that *tenure* should end @ age 70, converting to 5yr NTT contracts.
The changing distribution of law faculty age over the last 50 years is wild. In 1971, the most common age of faculty was their 30s. In 2017, most common was 60s. In 1971, many more under 30 than over 70. In 2017, as many over 70 as under 40. dho.stanford.edu/wp-content/u...
For the evidence on causality of ADEA—> older faculty see Ashenfelter & Card (2002): davidcard.berkeley.edu/papers/manda...
Kiernan Mathews reposted
Replying to @erickelderman.bsky.social
There may be a role for @bigtenacademic.bsky.social to play, but this is likely not it. It’s a mature (67yo), high-functioning consortium w/$12M+ in rev & a HQ in Champaign, but it’s largely does prof dev, communities of practice & shared services, w/occasional forays into research (e.g. CTE). /1