Effective Transit Alliance

Effective Transit Alliance

@etany.org

ETA is a 501(c)(3) non-profit that advocates for high-quality, accessible, and forward-looking transit through internationally-inspired, technically-oriented analysis in greater New York and across the nation.

2.3K followers0 following764 posts

Pinned

The IBX is coming, and it should be automated. ETA’s newest report, released today, covers the benefits of automated light metro (ALM) technology in detail, and why now is the time for the MTA to incorporate automation into the project’s design. Read the report now: www.etany.org/reports/ibx-...

etany.orgNo Need to Wait: Automated Light Metro is Right for the IBX — Effective Transit Alliance New YorkNow that the IBX will be fully grade-separated thanks to the All Faiths tunnel, the IBX should be built as an automated light metro. 73% of all new grade-separated rapid transit lines in 2025 were aut...

The planned Interborough Express will bring better transit access and faster travel times to Brooklyn and Queens. In order for IBX’s smaller, light metro style vehicles to keep up with demand, it needs to be automated.

View full thread

Important design elements for automation such as platform screen doors would add 0.75% to IBX’s current budget if planned for from the very start, but as a retrofit could cost nearly 10x more, based on examples from Paris and Hong Kong.

The planned Interborough Express will bring better transit access and faster travel times to Brooklyn and Queens. In order for IBX’s smaller, light metro style vehicles to keep up with demand, it needs to be automated.

View full thread

ALM can fill the gap by providing the level of service necessary to keep IBX from being over-capacity. This technology isn’t new—it’s already used for the JFK AirTrain here in New York, and for 73% of new rapid transit lines around the world.

Automation is necessary for IBX, but it doesn’t have to be expensive. Now is the time to incorporate ALM standards into the design. If we save it for later, the cost of retrofitting the IBX would be enormous.

The planned Interborough Express will bring better transit access and faster travel times to Brooklyn and Queens. In order for IBX’s smaller, light metro style vehicles to keep up with demand, it needs to be automated.

Automated light metro (ALM) systems provide high-frequency, reliable, and exceptionally safe service around the world—and frequency is crucial for IBX, where the ease of transferring can make or break a rider’s willingness to use transit.

But capacity also plays an essential role here. Ridership projections continue to grow, with one estimating that IBX will need to handle more riders than Phase 1 of the Second Avenue Subway—not even accounting for future transit oriented development.

"A group of transit wonks wants the MTA to say dōmo arigatō, Mr. Roboto and institute automated train operation for the upcoming Interborough Express — a revolutionary change that could allow the MTA to carry 50 percent more riders than the agency currently projects."

Streetsblog NYC@nyc.streetsblog.org

Transit wonks want the MTA to fully automate the planned IBX light-rail line between Brooklyn and Queens. But their proposal would likely enrage organized labor, which wants two workers on every single train in the subway system. buff.ly/72XT7jZ

"The MTA should design its planned [IBX] as a fully automated system from the beginning in order to ensure it can accommodate its frequency and capacity needs without having to undergo a costly retrofit in the future, a new report from [ETA] argues." www.amny.com/news/automat...

amny.comAutomating the IBX will ensure it can run faster, handle more riders, at a lower cost: reportThe MTA should design its planned Interborough Express (IBX) line as a fully automated system from the beginning in order to ensure it can accommodate its

"'Now it’s time for them to continue the good work and select the right technology for the line: automated light metro,' said Blair Lorenzo, the ETA’s executive director, in a statement. 'Automation allows for frequent trains at all times of the day at a low cost.'"

Effective Transit Alliance reposted

The MTA is beginning the environmental impact process for the 125 St Subway. Right now the project is focused tunnels, with station and other infrastructure to come later. Deep tunnels, however, would lock in the project's main downsides: depth and cost. www.bloomberg.com/news/article...

bloomberg.comNYC’s Planned Harlem Crosstown Subway Gets Environmental ReviewNew York’s Metropolitan Transportation Authority is starting an environmental review of a proposed crosstown subway line along Harlem’s 125th Street that could serve an estimated 164,000 weekday rider...

As ETA has detailed, at around $7.7B for 1.25 mi, this extension would be by far the most expensive subway on Earth—and so deep that it would require 5+ mins just to reach the platforms. Now is the time for the MTA to push for a shallower, cheaper, more usable subway: www.etany.org/reports/digg...

etany.orgDigging Out of a Very Deep Hole: Saving Billions on 125th Street — Effective Transit Alliance New YorkA 125 St subway should be a slam dunk. But at $7.7B and with stations more than 100 ft underground, it would be the most expensive subway in the world, and cost riders more than 5 minutes every trip b...

The MTA is looking for ways to improve passenger wayfinding via improved screens and announcements. Better tech is good on paper, ETA's Blair Lorenzo told the New York Groove, but the real question is if it will actually be used to improve the rider experience, and not simply blast more noise.

The New York Groove@nygroove.nyc

actually relevant updates on station screens? announcements you're able to clearly hear and understand??? a brave new world awaits the MTA, @timdonnelly.com reports nygroove.nyc/the-mta-is-a...

When it comes to announcements, the current status quo on NY's subways & buses is untenable. Transit in New York is too damn loud. Good announcement design would provide actionable information while letting riders travel in peace. Read ETA's report: www.etany.org/briefs/too-d...

etany.orgToo Damn Loud: Announcements on NYC Transit are Out of Control — Effective Transit Alliance New YorkThe seemingly-endless onslaught of announcements on NY transit not only annoys riders, but impairs accessibility, making navigating transit far more difficult than it needs to be.

ETA is here in Berlin and will be all week for InnoTrans to bring the best insights back to New York from the biggest public transit showcase in the world! If you'd like to meet with our team while we are here, we'd love to hear from you, feel free to drop us a message!

The New York Groove sat down with ETA to discuss the onslaught of unnecessary announcements facing NY riders. This type of noise pollution not only annoys riders, but trains them to not listen to announcements. As the NY Groove's tag puts it, "Better Things are Possible."

The New York Groove@nygroove.nyc

An advocacy group says: "the trains are too damn loud!" Here's their plan, released yesterday, to address subway noise pollution nygroove.nyc/subway-noise...

Effective Transit Alliance reposted

On the Berlin S-Bahn and the London Underground, the proportion is about half that.

ETA measured that on a 40 minutes trip from one end of the 7 train to another, nearly a full 25% of the time was filled by announcements. That makes it hard to talk with traveling companions, read a book, or even just travel in solitude.

ETA measured that on a 40 minutes trip from one end of the 7 train to another, nearly a full 25% of the time was filled by announcements. That makes it hard to talk with traveling companions, read a book, or even just travel in solitude.

The best announcements are be clear, concise, and based on actionable information. All other noise only makes travel harder and more annoying for everyone, especially for the visually impaired and for those who don't speak English as a first language. Read more: www.etany.org/briefs/too-d...

etany.orgToo Damn Loud: Announcements on NYC Transit are Out of Control — Effective Transit Alliance New YorkThe seemingly-endless onslaught of announcements on NY transit not only annoys riders, but impairs accessibility, making navigating transit far more difficult than it needs to be.

Another lesson they should learn is that NIMBYs are going to NIMBY. Many engineering choices are apparently being made to minimize disruption, but the number of Phase 1 complaints shows that they didn’t.

MTA planners should be more concerned about the project’s long-term benefits to New Yorkers than the short periods when construction noise and heavy trucks will dominate.

TONIGHT, August 28, come join ETA for TOD: Transit-Oriented Drinks, August! Join us for drinks, transit discussion, and transit advocacy. Tonight, Friday, August 28 6-8 PM Vanderbilt Market Vanderbilt Avenue & 45 Street Behind Grand Central All are welcome!

This Friday, August 28, come join ETA for TOD: Transit-Oriented Drinks, August! Join us for drinks, transit discussion, and transit advocacy. Friday, August 28 6-8 PM Vanderbilt Market Vanderbilt Avenue & 45 Street Behind Grand Central All are welcome!

According to a CB10 presentation in June, it appears the @mta.info may have reverted its plans to make 116 St on Phase 2 of the Second Avenue Subway an elevator-only station with a below-platform mezzanine. It now appears to be a standard above-platform mezzanine with escalators.

View full thread

According to a CB10 presentation in June, it appears the @mta.info may have reverted its plans to make 116 St on Phase 2 of the Second Avenue Subway an elevator-only station with a below-platform mezzanine. It now appears to be a standard above-platform mezzanine with escalators.

This is a great change, if confirmed. Riders won't have to go all the way down just to go back up again. They'll be able to take a short escalator ride to a shallow station. Moreover, the mezzanine is small, not full-length, saving money and minimizing surface disruption.