She’d rather die than let it go: My latest #WhyIsThisSongNo1? on @slate.com is about pop overlord Taylor+her 4th smash in 12mos “Patient Zero.” Misbegotten title aside…what’s up w/the #Hot100 success+meh reviews? How does Tay’s ubiquity help on the charts & hurt w/haters? Wanna party? She’s got you.
Chris Molanphy
Chris Molanphy
@cmolanphy.bsky.social
Chart analyst/pop critic. Host of podcast #HitParadePod. Writer of Slate's #WhylsThisSongNo1? Author of book #OldTownRoad. Feet on the ground, reaching for the stars. (Pronouns—he/him/his.)
2.8K followers296 following768 posts
While perusing the new #Billboard200, even before I read this @keithcaulfield.bsky.social story, I noticed Taylor, Drake+Beatles in the Top5—all w/reissues—& figured it had to be a first. I group these 3 acts together a lot cuz they’re the ones that have pulled seemingly impossible chart feats…[1/2]
In a way it’s too bad Kendrick Lamar didn’t reissue an album this week (um…bonus tracks on GNX?) cuz then all 4 of the titans of the #Hot100 would be dominating the #Billboard200 simultaneously. The Beatles, Drake, Taylor + Kendrick are, to date, the only 4 acts to lock down the #Hot100 Top 5. [2/2]
They say you gotta stay hungry: My new #HitParadePod on @slate.com is another in my #NearMissHits series—No2s, 11s & 41s that became legendary. This time…the ’80s: how Go West went south of the Top40…how a No11 Stevie Nicks hit outlasted her Top10s…how the Boss missed No1 thanks to another MTV icon
Available at the finest booksellers: www.dukeupress.edu/old-town-road
I’m getting in late here, but @augetoffmygold.bsky.social nails it in this all-encompassing explainer of the “Choosin Texas” phenomenon. He covers all the angles I’ve been prattling on about in articles+podcasts since August & more besides. The analogy to Teddy Swims 2yrs ago is especially astute.
Wrote about all of it. Tried to, anyway. www.billboard.com/music/chart-...
Just because they can: my latest #HitParadePod on @slate.com connects the late great Dolly Parton + currently dominant Ella Langley. How’d Dolly stay country while crossing pop—and what did she bequeath Ella’s generation, who are “Choosin’ Texas” while topping the pops? Talk about a cup of ambition.
It happened: Ella’s “Texas” has taken the #Hot100 wks@No1 record. (I give Mariah 2 Christmases to get it back…) Wanna know how + why? I offer my latest @slate.com #WhyIsThisSongNo1? column (slate.trib.al/Da3cHmt) or my chat w/Wesley Morris on @nytimes.com Cannonball: www.nytimes.com/2026/09/17/p...
P.S. Huge thanks to @lindsayzoladz.bsky.social for shouting out my Cannonball chat w/Wesley about “Choosin’ Texas” at the end of the latest installment of her @nytimes.com column #TheAmplifier. I am indeed a loyal reader! www.nytimes.com/2026/09/22/a...
I loved joining Wesley Morris to talk about Ella Langley’s #Hot100 record-setter “Choosin’ Texas,” on his @nytimes.com podcast #Cannonball. We get into the merits of the song…why some audiences haven't heard it…why country music is having a moment + what our current hits say about the national mood.
Hey @tombreihan.bsky.social, happy mutual birthday to my fellow chart-chronicler. Here's a thematically appropriate banger—if Billboard had launched the Modern Rock chart just 6 months sooner in '88, I'll bet you would've gotten to write about it for #AlternativeNumberOnes. Have a great day! 🎂
UPDATE: I called it—“Jolene” reenters@ No16, “I Will Always Love You” debuts@ No27. (First #Hot100 appearance ever for the latter!) I’m esp.proud I called which returning hit would be biggest—“IWALY” is more apropos to the moment but I just knew…folks love “Jolene.” www.billboard.com/music/chart-...
Looking for silver linings on this sad, sad day—want to put this prediction out there now… On next week’s #Hot100 I look forward to this immortal No1 country, No60 pop song—already her top Spotify track—finally becoming the Top 40 pop hit it has long deserved to be. Rest in Power to a legend. 💔
A “fun” read from @totcharts.bsky.social+a must-read for bellow chart junkies—even as it will not restore your faith in either the music biz or artist fandoms. I learned a few things—I missed that 6ix9ine leaked the #Hot100 formula & forgot Dua’s “Levitating” (likely) got robbed from a rightful No1.
Chris Molanphy reposted
Incredible bluegrass song. Incredibly a Billy Joel cover. Thanks @cmolanphy.bsky.social for turning me on to this on your Billy Joel episode of hit parade. youtu.be/40wdYXbpv5U?...
Looking for silver linings on this sad, sad day—want to put this prediction out there now… On next week’s #Hot100 I look forward to this immortal No1 country, No60 pop song—already her top Spotify track—finally becoming the Top 40 pop hit it has long deserved to be. Rest in Power to a legend. 💔
Doesn't take a crystal ball to see: my #WhyIsThisSongNo1? series on @slate.com takes another look at “Choosin’ Texas” now that it’s about to tie an all-time #Hot100 record. Already #SongOfTheSummer, it’s pulling other country songs into the pop Top5. Country’s having a moment—but also…it’s the data.
And I say…it’s all right. My latest #HitParadePod —now live on @slate.com—chronicles the hit the Beatles left on the table: “Here Comes the Sun,” George’s Abbey Road deep cut. It’s now their most-played digital song, over any Lennon–McCartney joint…how did Harrison’s self-care inspire a stealth hit?
It’s all coming back: my latest #HitParadePod —now live on @slate.com—is about Canadian chanteuse Céline Dion, training like an Olympian for her stage comeback. We go deep on her imperial ’90s when she turned flops into smashes & supercharged the soundtrack. Is your mom’s fave finally…a little cool?
I enjoyed talking w/Lawrence Peryer for his cultural conversation podcast @thetonearm.com. We had a wide-ranging chat—from Taylor Swift to James Taylor…why I loved Bruce Hornsby & couldn't abide Bon Jovi…why Billy Idol + Pointer Sisters are great #HitParadePod topics…& why Ella Langley is still No1.
Here’s an audiogram excerpt of my appearance on @thetonearm.com podcast—about why, after all these years, the #Hot100 is still our trusted flagship pop chart. And why a song’s chart peak is not always the last word on its legacy—from “Tiny Dancer” to “Running Up That Hill.”
In @newyorker.com, the great @luxante.bsky.social on Daft Punk’s master single: “We need ‘Get Lucky’ too, because we need romance, or at least hope. The struggle we face is not just political but existential…we need to dance and to love, so that we don’t forget what we’re ultimately fighting for.” 😭
Anybody playing Catalogues, the new pattern-recognition game from @newyorker.com? Today’s installment (Fri 31 Jul) was—you might say—up my alley. I got it in 1—if you’re a fellow #Hot100 chart nerd you will too. P.S.One of the names in the stack will make you sad for him. 1 guess 😻 🟢 🟢 🟢 🟢 🟢 🟢 🟢
Allow him to reintroduce himself: my new #HitParadePod —live on @slate.com—celebrates 30yrs of JayZ rocking the mic. His 4 #Hot100 No1s are teamups w/female singers & you can organize his career around them: Striver Jay…Imperial Jay…Mogul Jay + Elder Statesman Jay. He’s never had girl problems, son.
It’s a gas…it’s a hit: my new #HitParadePod on @slate.com is about Pink Floyd & the alltime album-chart record #TheDarkSideoftheMoon still holds. How does this LP keep seducing new generations of HS stoners+vinyl buyers? What competing LPs are creeping up on Floyd’s record? slate.com/podcasts/hit...
Don’t fear the repeat: my new #HitParadePod on @slate.com is about 2-Hit Wonders—fluky acts who could’ve been one-hitters but made lightning strike twice. It’s all about the hit gap—the best 2HWs come back years, even a decade after their 1st hit…from Gloria Gaynor to Murray Head to Golden Earring.
Fun w/charts: The news that Robert Smith (!) guests on the new Stones LP (!!) sent me back to fall ’89 to see if my suspicion was right that the Cure & Stones mixed it up on the #Hot100. Boy howdy, did they! One week after this, the Cure’s biggest-ever pop hit rose to its No2 peak; Stones held@ No5.
“You are Robert Smith from the Cure!” Mick Jagger recalls the unexpected moment that led to a Rolling Stones collaboration
I am a longtime, diehard @slate.com #PoliticalGabfest fan—literally since week one, over 2 decades ago—so I was thrilled to hear Gabfest host David Plotz shout out my latest #HitParadePod toward the end of this week’s show! The full Gabfest episode can be heard here: slate.com/podcasts/pol...
Wow—the #PoliticalGabfest hyped my show again this week! This time, it was promo for the #HitParadePod Power Ballads episode, and David Plotz got @jdickerson.bsky.social & Emily Bazelon to chime in. You haven't lived until you’ve heard David sing a bit of REO Speedwagon’s “Can’t Fight This Feeling.”
What can I say about the last days of @slate.com #CultureGabfest? It’s been my honor to help @juliaturner.bsky.social @thehighsign.bsky.social & Steve Metcalf curate Summer Strut—their annual collection of hot-time bops. I’m on this week to help them strut into the sunset. slate.com/podcasts/cul...
They remembered they loved her: my latest #WhyIsThisSongNo1? article on @slate.com is about Taylor Swift’s instant chart-topper from #ToyStory5. Why’d it take her so long to score a No1 soundtrack hit? And why did country radio welcome her back like her 15-year pivot to pop never happened? Giddy up.
Forever yours—faithfully: What is a power ballad? My new #HitParadePod episode on @slate.com explores how these climaxing…cringy…kinda awesome mini-melodramas took over the charts in the ’70s–’80s—from Styx to Skid Row. Does a PB require spandex…or an Olympic voice? And who’s keeping them alive now?
I am a longtime, diehard @slate.com #PoliticalGabfest fan—literally since week one, over 2 decades ago—so I was thrilled to hear Gabfest host David Plotz shout out my latest #HitParadePod toward the end of this week’s show! The full Gabfest episode can be heard here: slate.com/podcasts/pol...
And of course, lest I forget, here’s that latest #HitParadePod episode—the “Near-Miss Hits: ’70s Edition” that David shouted out. Also available wherever you listen to podcasts: slate.com/podcasts/hit...
Guess I can retire—an article I wrote for @slate.com 6 years ago became an answer in the semifinals of Netflix’s #PopCultureJeopardy! The article, from the start of the pandemic—my #WhyIsThisSongNo1? piece on The Weeknd’s “Blinding Lights”: slate.com/culture/2020... “FLAILING…ARMS & LEGS” FTW.
Live&let die? Think again! My new #HitParadePod on @slate.com is a tour of near-miss hits—No2s, 11s & 41s that became legendary. In this episode…the ’70s: How’d Wings’ No2 Bond theme outlast a No1 ballad? Why’d Steely Dan’s yacht rockers miss the Top10? How’d Elton’s blue-jean baby miss Casey Kasem?
Announcing the return of my @slate.com podcast #HitParadePod! We now offer single-episode topics more frequently in a conversational style. For our comeback I go deep on ’80s shapeshifter + Rock Hall inductee Billy Idol. How’d the sneer king fuse punk w/pop+dance+goth+metal to rule MTV & the charts?
This @billboard.com factoid should come w/10 asterisks. Sure…technically ‘Number Ones’ is “new” to the Billboard 200’s Top10 this week…but for over a month in 2009 it was America’s top-seller, excluded from the chart only cuz of a now-defunct rule that purged catalog titles. A dubious MJ chart feat.
As part of Slate’s commemoration of my 100th episode of #HitParadePod, this week EIC Hillary Frey interviewed me for her weekly Friday email to Slate Plus members. It was fun reminiscing about how charts have changed, why Casey Kasem mattered, favorite HP episodes and my recent musical comfort food.
This ranking is fun but w/all due respect to @augetoffmygold.bsky.social & the Billboard gang, ranking JT’s “SexyBack” No1 & the still-superior, Pitchfork-poptimism totem “My Love” No37 is revisionist madness (not like opinion changed in 20yrs—cf @tombreihan.bsky.social’s ratings on The Number Ones)
The 100 Best Songs of 2006: Staff Picks
On a new #HitParadePod –The Bridge, my guest @slate.com editor Forrest Wickman says the trick of both my podcast & column #WhyIsThisSongNo1? is making connections between modern chart-toppers & hits of yore—an Archies-to-Huntr/x continuum. Plus—Casey Kasem trivia & words of gratitude from your host.
Also! While #HitParadePod –The Bridge episodes are only for Slate Plus members, non-Plus listeners can now hear Pt2 of our March show celebrating our milestone 100th episode. I tell the story of chart king Casey Kasem—how he launched AT40, created the LDD & survived a Dead Dog tape. Pts1&2 are here:
Chris Molanphy reposted
If you missed it last week, check out our annual Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Voter's Guide episode - this year with an actual voter!!! Special thanks to @cmolanphy.bsky.social for guesting while in town for PopCon at USC
It was a blast joining the #BeyondYachtRock gang— @jdryznar.bsky.social @hollywoodsteve.bsky.social Hunter & Dave—in the Fart Dungeon™ for a #RockHall ballot podcast chat. What genre is Billy Idol? Why can’t we agree on Mariah? Why do JD & NO belong together? And why does everybody diss the Crowes?
Billboard Bildungsroman: For the 100th episode of #HitParadePod on @slate.com I go deep on my chart-geek history. Part 1: my musical memoir, Solid Gold to Nirvana. Part 2: the story of Casey Kasem, original #AmericanTop40 host—how he nationalized countdowns, invented the LDD & survived the Dead Dog.
I joined @djlouiexiv.bsky.social on his #PopPantheon podcast along with pop critic @popsamcam.bsky.social to debate the past & current state of the #Hot100 and what a No1 hit means. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/d...
It was a blast joining the #BeyondYachtRock gang— @jdryznar.bsky.social @hollywoodsteve.bsky.social Hunter & Dave—in the Fart Dungeon™ for a #RockHall ballot podcast chat. What genre is Billy Idol? Why can’t we agree on Mariah? Why do JD & NO belong together? And why does everybody diss the Crowes?
Chris Molanphy reposted
I’m back playing #Oscars pundit on the music categories for #BelowTheLine podcast. First up…Best Score—Louis Weeks, Jennie Armon & I discuss: Will the Academy go for 𝘉𝘶𝘨𝘰𝘯𝘪𝘢 weirdness or 𝘍𝘳𝘢𝘯𝘬𝘦𝘯𝘴𝘵𝘦𝘪𝘯 lushness? Why’s 𝘏𝘢𝘮𝘯𝘦𝘵’s best tune ineligible? And does Göransson have the prize locked for 𝘚𝘪𝘯𝘯𝘦𝘳𝘴?
Here’s the other #Oscars podcast chat I took part in w/the #BelowTheLine gang. In this episode Louis Weeks, Tom Peyton & I talk Best Song: Can Diane Warren be stopped? Is the 𝘛𝘳𝘢𝘪𝘯 𝘋𝘳𝘦𝘢𝘮𝘴 song extra-dreamy? Can the 𝘚𝘪𝘯𝘯𝘦𝘳𝘴 song pull an upset…or should we give Team 𝘒𝘗𝘰𝘱 𝘋𝘦𝘮𝘰𝘯 𝘏𝘶𝘯𝘵𝘦𝘳𝘴 the statue now?