Post

New Blog Post πŸ“ Everyone is entitled to their opinion. However. As teachers, its important that we keep our opinions to ourselves and offer a balanced view. The balance is difficult, but in an increasingly political world, we could have undue influence. open.substack.com/pub/joel1201...

open.substack.comThe Weight of a Teacher's Words: The Importance of Being NeutralWhy a teacher's voting habits should stay a secret to protect the intellectual freedom of every student. You may feel you are doing right, but you may be enabling the wrong.

1 repost3 likes

For mathematicians, a bit of More or Less can work wonders, and you can usually isolate a short segment debunking whatever bullshit Farage or the Daily Fail is putting out, all under the guise of understanding statistics in the real world.

Some of the graphs on campaign flyers make great examples of what not to do. As I recall, there were some prize examples from the Lib Dems where the graphs bore little relation to the numbers printed next to them.

Nice post. I agree, but personally I do find the line difficult to hold sometimes. I'm conscious my students will be able to vote soon so I want to know that they can do so from a more informed position. That means, in my view, sharing news stories about those with (potential) political power.

In reality, though, that often means it's the 'scandals' which get attention, and it's hard to dissociate the personal from the political. Eg Farage breaking the ministerial code or Johnson doing... well, lots! (and for balance, I include Labour / Lib dem etc too - but they're rarely as bad!)

I think it's important that young people understand the moral character of those who might be courting their vote. I think highlighting when those people have objectively broken the rules is qualitatively different from saying "I don't agree with their views on..."

I'll try to temper this by saying "I make no comment on their political views..." but I'd be being disingenuous if I said this wasn't also influenced by my own views on the politics too.

In the US "both sides" is often one side stating facts and the other side stating debunked claims. There is only one side to climate change, vaccine efficacy, the moon landings, and the shape of the Earth. There is no balanced view on these and other issues.