Joe Emison on Mythryl: “NY Magazine is a usually a great publication, but this article is a…”

NY Magazine is a usually a great publication, but this article is a logically incoherent “flooding the zone with shit” take. G&T programs for sure are imperfect, but this long article adds nothing useful to the discussion.

New York Magazine@nymag.com

Proponents of Gifted & Talented programs have promoted the notion that the smartest children need extra enrichment to reach their potential and that we can measure the beneficial impact on the children who receive it. But not a single part of this story is true, reports Katie Arnold-Ratliff.

nymag.comThe Mirage of the Gifted ChildCritics say the systems we use to educate the brightest kids are flawed and exclusionary. What if it’s the very premise of giftedness that’s faulty?

12/6/26, 6:18 am1 repost0 likes

Post