Post

If TiKTok wasn’t a benefit for Chinese intel, they would sell. They could make a killing. But it’s not about the money

1.1K reposts7.5K likes

If they want our data they can get it anyway. There are no privacy laws and Temu has the same data. If they want to influence our elections, they can use X and Facebook.

I gotta ask though the Russians are exploiting meta and x (x and truthsocial are now us right wing govt propaganda machines- meta coming along soon) so how are those not bad for national security as well - if that is really the argument #doublestandards #cambridgeanalytica

Adam, I respect the hell out of you, but “China bad and connected to TikTok” ain’t gonna cut it for me. What’s the threat EXACTLY!? None of this vague “well, they could use it to influence American’s opinions.” 100 million Americans are using TikTok, tread carefully

Personally I don't believe in banning tik tok, whilst anybody from Russia and China can go on Facebook and Twitter in masses and spread any amount of conspiracy, hate and lies without recourse. That makes no sense to me. Which is the biggest security threat?

I mean, who needs Russia and China anyway? We have MAGA. They do a pretty good job on their own of spreading conspiracies and misinformation. The Russians and China don’t even have to pay them!

Are Facebook and Twitter collecting data on the Russian and Chinese citizens that are using the platforms and giving that data to the US Government? Are they controlling and influencing what Russia/China are seeing? If the answer is yes, then TikToc is just doing the same. If no, we have a problem

Why should they be forced to sell a profitable business just to make some American business rich? If the tables were turned and China was forcing @META to sell, you’d be singing a different tune. This is bull.

You noted that they don’t. I don’t think we should judge our policies by those of China. Otherwise what’s the point of the 1st Amendment? Someone please say what law TikTok violated here? And what protections do we have that trump admin won’t be able to get our data from X or Meta!

Meta complies with the laws in each country just like TikTok has complied with the laws in this country. Notice that not one of these legislators attacking TikTok can show it violated U.S. laws. This is BS. Just trying to enrich another American billionaire.

Pretty sure Meta is abusing our data and information more than TikTok. Getting banned as a user on TikTok is relatively easy. Meta and X by far spread more misinformation and negative influence.

I was on Twitter, then Musk bought it, changed the name to "X" and turned it into a hate fest - got rid of any fact checking and controlled all the speech. It is awful! Now Zuck is following in Musk's footsteps. "A lie can fly halfway around the world while the truth is still getting its boots on."

No, insurance companies and board members dictating how drs treat patients. Mental health deserts for decades. Underfunded public schools with standardized tests, not educating, but pumping out factory workers (if they live thru the school day). Gun rights protected while women’s are girls stripped

2) current statistics show 1 in 3 girls and 1 in 5 boys are sexually assaulted in this country! This is what is destroying our youths mental health and their lives. TikTok is a welcomed respite where people can authenticity come together.

All social media benefits different countries, all US based social media is similarly dodgy. Twitter being the worst and what are you going to do about it? Something I hope. Facebook helped radicalise people in the U.K. and caused Brexit. We need strong laws to control it. Not bans.

Please. Zuck paid Targeted Victory to start this campaign 3 years ago. You’d ban all the apps if you were so worried about foreign government intel. Pass laws that protect our data in general rather than banning an app that brings people joy in this dystopian world.

The owner : Zhang Yiming (Chinese: 张一鸣; born April 1, 1983) is a Chinese Internet entrepreneur. He founded ByteDance in 2012, developed the news aggregator Toutiao and the video sharing platform Douyin (internationally known as TikTok). Why is this different from Elon Musk or Mark Zuckerberg ?

They should all be regulated. This was my point when I wrote to my senators but the response I got was “but China.” China, sure. But IF China did sell to an American company and that American was Musk or Zuckerberg or Bannon or Mnuchin or Trump etc., America gets be torn apart too, just from within.

Are we going to stop playing the Pussy. Come up with excuses to block THE Chinese SM? All Biden / trump need to declare to Xi Jinping: "Listen Dude, you ban our - Google, Facebook, Aassbook,, X , Y OR Z whatever - we ban your SM. PERIOD!!!"

TikTok will absorb the loss of American followers and still make lots of money. Don't be like Tom Cotton, who made an international laughing stock of himself when questioning the CEO of TikTok. "Senator, I'm Singaporean."

TikTok is no worse for Americans than Google or Meta. They all need to be regulated to better protect our privacy and security. TT provides information and value to 186 million Americans and a great way for us to educate and inform each other. Zuckerberg just doesn't like the competition.

Actual proof of this would be nice. Zero of the usual procedures were followed in taking a business' right to exist in the U.S. away. Yet there's ample proof Russia meddled in our elections via our social media. What actions have been required to mitigate this? ALL big tech needs more oversight.

This. Exactly. Though it's less about intel in the classic sense. Rather it's about using the algorithm to subtly get viewers to dislike and doubt our government just a tiny bit every day. Still, they'll sell and take the money if faced with it being shut down

i feel like you should migrate to X because the target community here is definitely not for this point of view… They can’t sell because of the chinese tech involved in creating the algorithm because it’s against the law 🫤 But it is totally okay if facebook/meta hands our data to direct threats!!!

Bull shit. I’d rather see Face Book stopped. Our private data was stolen and sold by Zuckerberg. I’m sure China already has it. Do you realize how many folks make their living on TikTok? It’s always us that get screwed. Some right wing nut job oligarch wants to buy it.

So please tell us tik tok lovers adam exactly what intel the chinese can gather. I mean we get hacked every day. Wasnt the treasury dept just hacked? Aside from learning the hottest dance moves what in the world are they getting!!!

I wonder what the biggest worry is here. The intelligence and personal insight they can collect on any user anywhere or all the data collectively feeding their AI and how that will be used.

Would Facebook sell to China to make a killing? Its algorithms and user base are everything it has. With Trump in power, surely he is going to use social media platforms for Intel. Should the Canada buy Facebook- or ban it? Trump may be an even greater threat to security than XI Ping.

You think they’d make more money selling the company than they would if they continued operating all over the world except in the U.S.? Are you joking? Also, what intel do you suspect they gathering that they can’t get by other means? Adam, I usually agree with you, but wtf?

If Justices were Justices instead of incels... America wouldn't be the Titanic... About to hit the fucking iceberg They could rule justly But it's not about justice is it...

The CCP uses its brainwashing ability to make the lower-class people work hard for it, defeat the Kuomintang, and eventually control China, making the lower-class people enslaved and persecuted by it, just like a cult controls its followers. The American people should not underestimate this.

I wonder why Tim Tok or any company for that matter, should play by the rules? It seems clear enough to me that the American voters want people who break the law rather than follow it.

This is a logical fallacy, it's called a false dichotomy. It implies that there are only two choices when in reality there is a spectrum. As much as I enjoy your stance on tRump, you sometimes remind me that you are in fact a Republican.

Well, look at why Trump wants TikTok—Easy exposure to millions of people he can easily feed a steady diet of confabulations and lies to without question. He said as much. This is about control and power not money and dance videos.

They have 1 billion users, losing the u.s would only be a lose of 130 million users and I mean yeah, I’d somewhat agree they have better marketing in the American ecosystem I don’t believe it’s enough money to forcibly sell their company for that reason.

It is absolutely about the money. Media moguls don’t like TikTok because it’s free, faster, more agile & beyond their control. We are able to see breaking news here on TikTok DAYS (72 hours or more) before it makes it to NBC, CBS or ABC; 12 to 48 hours before we see it in print or on MSNBC or CNN.

TEMU scares me more than Tik Tok. When you read TEMU's disclaimers and see what you are agreeing to by buying from them, it's beyond Orwellian. If you buy from TEMU, you are agreeing to let them data mine your emails to see what your purchasing interests are. It's a fatal privacy parasite.

I don't purchase from Temu, Shein, Ali express etc. Can you tell me more? I genuinely want to know due to the issues you mention. I guess I could read it without buying...

So they get intel on stupid Americans, so what? Especially if it is benefiting those stupid Americans? Many people have a thriving business because of it. It is not like they are trying to plan an insurrection. Lol

Right, it's about the Oligarchy not wanting the youth to share political information with one another which would enable them to organize against Republicans and others in the Monied Class. Once they shut down TikTok, the rich will ban wherever the kids go to next.

TikTok has allowed people to supplement their incomes so they can raise their families or quit jobs that were detrimental to their mental health. And they actually make good money, whether it's selling on the TikTok shop or the creator's fund. It's about keeping people poor.

Exactly! It's hilariously ironic it's only TikTok they care about an not Meta, X, or Google considering the data mining of those apps hasn't been brought into question. By banning the app it's just another way to keep people poor, and uninformed in a world of misinformation!

So by that logic then Zuck or Musk could make a killing if they sold, but since they are a benefit for the American intel they won’t sell. Don’t be petty and take cheap shots like that. You are way above that MAGA nonsense, and it doesn’t suit you.

Yes, it is - on this side of the Pacific. Major Trump donor ($Ms) owns a big chuck of TicTok parent company. Trump changed his position after a meeting with said donor. Dude must have picked up the tab for lunch!

Probably not nearly as many Russian bots that have been brainwashing the mentally challenged MAGAts on FB, Xitter and Lie Unsocial since before the 2016 election.

I think we need to force Zuckerberg and Elon to sell their platforms, they are clear and present danger to democracy, we should protect against threats both domestic and foreign..

You're kidding right? You think that in the hands of Elon or some other US conglomerate it would be any different? You just want to make sure that it's on the 'right side'. Kettle black much?

Maybe it's to protect their IP. Would we be OK with being forced to sell off American companies to be able to do business in China? Btw, Fox News (also foreign-owned) has done far more damage to America.

Gathering and selling is not the problem. Control by a government hostile to the U.S. and our citizens is abad thing. The arguments and the justices’ questions from today frame the problem well.

The ability to manipulate the algorithm. Think How musk used Twitter to help trump get elected would be a similar level of control - except the CCP is an adversarial foreign power that is likely gearing up to go to war with the US, and tik tok is way more addictive than twitter

That’s a joke. They can have all my data. You can’t tell me Zuck and Elon don’t sell our sh*t. And what about SHEIN and Temu?????? We can keep the garbage buying apps but not our town hall app???

I sincerely don’t get why folks think this is about data or privacy. Musk buying twitter had a real and tangible impact on the US election bc he was able to manipulate the algorithm. But we are okay with an adversarial foreign power exerting a similar level of influence?

Like FOX News? Like Facebook? What exactly is the “significant threat” of watching reels of people being funny or stupid vs being fed propaganda and misinformation

You could apply this to Apple, Google, Microsoft, Meta, etc. they have massive data centers with zillabites of our personal data. Sounds like Tik Tok said fuck you to protection payments.

I think people are not putting 2 and 2 together that the American companies are about to be bullied into being like X now. Meta is publicly degrading itself now and when will YT follow that lead?

This is an L take… if the US government was so concerned about our data they wouldn’t ban a single Chinese app but ban the thousands of them on the App Store including Temu.

But again, why do I care if China is getting intel from TikTok as opposed to Musk or Zuck or the conservative groups trying to buy it? Who’s the more dangerous enemy? China who I know to be wary of or fellow Americans hell bent on spreading lies and propaganda through media?

It's about the control of information and money. Everything we do on the internet is collecting our data...Everything. So, if they were truly concerned, they would instead implement safeguards and regulation. The TikTok ban is BS

That’s quite the assumption. Do you think an American company that spent years building a global brand would sell just like that if it ran into the same opposition trying to grow in the Chinese market? Or would it pivot to other markets? Or wait for the political winds to change?