Post

I don't doubt that a lot of people are considering leaving, but perhaps someone could tell Nature how to write survey questions

16 reposts150 likes

I think the prospect of brain drain is real and very sad. It would be helpful for people at non US institutions to have a better sense of how many might leave; good polling data is valuable. It's also wasting the time of participants to ask them leading questions that are not informative.

As an example, "no" here could just mean "No I'm not a US researcher." There aren't any other options (apart from yes and no) and this is the first question in the survey.

Not to mention the use of "considering" - pretty much every academic I know is dreaming about leaving the US but most likely will not move out as it is not feasible for most people. Does that count as considering?