Post

This story is about the tiny minority of tenants who oppose the city’s plan to replace their crumbling old buildings with new ones—with zero tenant displacement!—because they want the city to spend money it does not have and will not get to renovate the old buildings instead.

This post is unavailable.

55 reposts390 likes

To be fair, even if the city decided to renovate the older buildings, that same tiny minority would still object since they'd... well... have to move out of the way of the renovators. Moving is a pain in the ass! I get it! Unfortunately, entropy sometimes comes faster for our homes than our bodies.

And if NYCHA waited for all the tenants to die, they’d be rightly raked over the coals for warehousing apartments.

Moving is a lot more than just a pain in the ass when they are trying to force you into an apartment that cannot accommodate your walker, and far away from your friends. This should have been handled a lot better and with more empathy and understanding of elderly residents who live together

If you read the article, the existing tenants have reasons to doubt that they will get equivalent housing in the new development, that similar projects have serious quality issues, that very little low income housing will be produced, and NYCHA estimates of rehab expense are dubious.

Oh, they have a plan - tax "every Wall Street transaction", whatever the hell that means. I think, taken literally, it would mean putting a giant drag on 401ks and pension funds. Good luck with that.

Their other idea is... getting rid of the mortgage interest tax deduction? Fellas, you mention that and voters will support sinking every public housing project into the sea

Those tenants are elderly, have really significant mobility and health problems, and don't want to be dispersed away from each other to smaller and shabby *temporary for several years* locations with no real guarantee they will ever be able to come back. The city fucked this up badly

The New York City Housing Authority has a seventy eight billion dollar maintenance backlog. Nobody quoted in opposition to the redevelopment plan has a credible plan to finance those repairs while keeping the existing buildings in place.

Reminded of somebody I know ranting to me about the De Blasio administration using hotels in their neighborhood as emergency housing for homeless people---before saying that, of course, they think the government should just provide everyone with housing for free.

Anyway, occasional reminder that attempting to get NYC tenant activists to explain how they would actually pay for the NYCHA’s maintenance backlog produced the classic “white ways of knowing and being” tweet.

Require 10,000 hours of non-academia labor prior to enrollment in a social science PhD challenge.

That one always baffled me because I'm pretty sure budgeting is not some sort of characteristically white thing to do. Pretty certain that if you want to maintain apartment buildings in like, Lagos or New Delhi or something you do need to pay people money to do it.

Decolonization is not a metaphor. It is not vibes, papers, or essays. It's when you stiff your contractors like Donald Trump did, but leftistly.