Post

a new Northwestern study found that "smart" TV makers often still spy on you even when you opt out. Vizio was particularly bad; completely ignoring opt out requests despite being fined $2.2 by the FTC in 2017 and a $17 million class action: watchingthewatchers.github.io/watchingthew...

43 reposts115 likes

I wonder how much technical literacy would help here. Most people outsource their home network to whatever company sets up their internet - which... I actually never framed it exactly like that before. Shit, that's terrifying.

they've been trying for years, I think what's most needed are for companies to be genuinely afraid of regulators again

Yeah, but that's still in a system where we're asking non-expert consumers to engage with the perennial trade-off, security vs convenience. It's a pain in the ass to get people who know better to make the right choice, and companies find gaps in regulations like teenage boys find boobies online.

smart tvs require internet access, so who set up your local network is irrelevant. You can avoid that by plugging in a streaming device, but that just pushes the problem to that device. Digital privacy regulations with serious penalties are the approach that would work.

You can maintain granular control over access and, importantly, you have visibility into who devices are trying to talk to. Even with a streaming device people still set up their TV. A single device reduces your exposure so you're not just shifting the problem, you're minimizing its surface area.

That requires far more technical expertise than just setting up your lan yourself. The tech skills of the average household are basically nonexistant.